Can I Just Use AI Instead of a Lawyer? The Smartest Choice Is …

Can I Just Use AI Instead of a Lawyer? The Smartest Choice Is an Experienced Lawyer Powered by AI

With artificial intelligence now able to draft contracts, analyse cases and generate “legal” answers in seconds, it’s natural to wonder: do I really still need a lawyer?

The short answer: yes, but not necessarily the kind you’re used to.
The future of legal advice isn’t AI versus lawyers; it’s lawyers who know how to use AI versus everyone else.

AI can process vast amounts of information and present it clearly, but it can’t read the room, sense risk tolerance, or understand commercial dynamics. The best legal outcomes happen when cutting-edge technology meets seasoned human judgement.

1. What AI Already Does Well

AI tools have transformed the way legal information is produced and shared.
Well-prompted, they can:

• Draft contracts or letters in seconds.
  
• Summarise long documents with impressive clarity.
  
• Compare multiple scenarios and highlight logical outcomes.
  
• Suggest plainer, clearer explanations than many lawyers once managed.

In other words, AI has raised the baseline of legal communication.
For routine or low-risk matters – such as drafting a simple NDA or checking a definition in a contract – AI can often get you 80 per cent of the way there.

That’s progress worth celebrating. Clients now expect speed, clarity and accessibility as standard.

But there’s still a critical 20 per cent that technology alone can’t deliver – and that 20 per cent is where real legal expertise lives.

2. Where AI Falls Short

Despite its sophistication, AI doesn’t understand context, nuance or consequence.

It can’t tell you:

• Whether that “standard” clause makes commercial sense for your deal.
  
• How much risk your business can tolerate.
  
• What strategy to take in a negotiation.
  
• When to compromise – and when to dig in.
  

AI can mirror patterns from data, but it can’t see the bigger picture that a lawyer builds from experience, empathy and commercial awareness.

AI gives you the words. A lawyer gives you the wisdom.

Without that human layer of interpretation, even the best-written contract can be strategically wrong for your situation.

3. The Power of the AI-Enabled Lawyer

The most effective lawyers today are those who use AI as a force multiplier, not a replacement.

By letting AI handle the repetitive groundwork – research, document formatting, first drafts – skilled lawyers free themselves to focus on the parts of legal advice that matter most: judgment, communication and strategy.

An AI-enabled lawyer can:

• Deliver faster results – administrative tasks are automated, so clients get answers sooner.
  
• Communicate more clearly – AI helps refine language and structure, cutting jargon.
  
• Spend more time thinking commercially – with routine work done, lawyers can focus on outcomes, not paperwork.
  
• Offer more empathetic advice – AI can even help test tone, ensuring advice lands well with different audiences.
  

In short, AI makes good lawyers better, more efficient, more thoughtful and more available to their clients.

4. The Real Risk: Lawyers Who Don’t Use AI

The real disruption isn’t AI replacing lawyers.
It’s AI replacing outdated ways of working.

Clients are no longer satisfied with slow, overly technical, opaque advice. They want clear guidance they can act on – and they want it fast.

Firms that ignore AI risk falling behind. Those that use it intelligently deliver work that’s:

• Faster to produce
  
• Easier to understand
  
• More commercially focused
  
• Better aligned with the client’s goals
  

That’s why the question isn’t “Will AI replace lawyers?”
It’s “Which lawyers are smart enough to use AI well?”

5. Why Human Insight Still Matters

Even the most advanced technology can’t replicate emotional intelligence, ethics or lived experience.

Lawyers bring critical skills that AI lacks entirely:

• Understanding people. A lawyer senses when a client needs reassurance, or when an opponent’s confidence is wavering.
  
• Assessing risk appetite. Businesses differ wildly in how much uncertainty they can stomach; AI can’t calibrate that.
  
• Reading the room. Whether in negotiation or litigation, success often depends on timing and tone.
  
• Making judgement calls. Knowing when to press a point or accept a concession comes only from experience.
  

AI can’t substitute those instincts – it can only support them.

That’s why the most valuable legal advice still depends on a human being who can interpret the law through the lens of your goals, your sector, and your relationships.

6. When AI Alone Might Be Enough – and When It Isn’t

For simple, low-risk matters, AI tools can be useful.
If you need a rough first draft of a short agreement or want to understand the meaning of a common legal term, AI can help you get started.

But once money, risk or relationships are on the line, for instance:

• entering a joint-venture agreement
  
• resolving a dispute
  
• selling or buying a company
  
• negotiating key contract terms
  

you need expert human judgement.

A small drafting error or a misread of tone could have expensive consequences. The right lawyer, enhanced by AI, can spot those issues instantly and guide you safely through.

7. What This Means for Clients

Choosing a lawyer who embraces AI isn’t about novelty, it’s about value.

With the right combination of expertise and technology, clients benefit from:

• Speed. Work is completed more efficiently without compromising quality.
  
• Clarity. AI-assisted drafting ensures documents are structured and readable.
  
• Cost-effectiveness. Automation reduces administrative time and helps control fees.
• Strategic depth. Lawyers have more capacity for big-picture thinking and negotiation planning.
  
• Consistency. AI helps maintain accuracy across large volumes of work.
  

In essence, clients get the best of both worlds: cutting-edge efficiency plus the wisdom, empathy and accountability that only experienced lawyers provide.

8. The Future of Legal Advice

The profession is changing fast and that’s a good thing.
AI is pushing lawyers to be clearer, faster and more commercially minded. It’s stripping away unnecessary complexity and bureaucracy.

But the essence of lawyering – human judgment in human situations – remains irreplaceable.

The best firms aren’t resisting AI; they’re integrating it. They see technology not as a threat, but as a way to spend more time on what clients truly value: insight, reassurance and results.

In Summary

AI can draft a contract… but it can’t tell you whether to sign it.

The smartest move isn’t to pick one over the other.
It’s to work with a lawyer who understands how to harness both, combining human expertise, empathy and commercial strategy with the speed, structure and clarity of AI.

That’s what “AI-Powered Lawyering” really means: not replacing lawyers with machines, but giving you the best version of both.

To hear Jonathan talking on the Law Firm Owners Podcast with host, Dan Warburton about How to Use ChatGPT and AI to Not Be Left Behind click HERE

And, if you have an issue that you would like an AI powered lawyer to discuss with you, please email wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net providing us with any relevant information ensuring that any call we have is as productive as possible or call us on 01444 708640. After this call, we can then email you a scope of work, fee estimate (or fixed fee quote if possible), and confirmation of any other points or information mentioned on the call.

 

 

VAT is charged at 20%.

This article is intended for general information only, applies to the law at the time of publication, is not specific to the facts of your case and is not intended to be a replacement for legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before relying on any of the information given. © Jonathan Lea Limited.

 

Photo by Vinícius Marçall on Unsplash