Investment Disputes
Resolving Investment Disputes: Equity and Debt Conflicts in UK Companies
Investing in a business, whether by purchasing shares or advancing debt, can be highly rewarding. Equity investments promise growth in ownership value and dividends, while debt finance provides fixed returns and security. However, when things do not go as planned, disputes can quickly arise. These conflicts can become highly disruptive, financially damaging, and emotionally draining for both investors and company directors.
At the Jonathan Lea Network, we specialise in resolving disputes over investments into UK companies. Our solicitors combine legal knowledge with commercial pragmatism to protect your position and achieve a fair resolution. We regularly advise SMEs, angel investors, venture capital funds, lenders, and entrepreneurs across a wide spectrum of investment disputes.
Common Types of Investment Disputes
1. Equity Investment Disputes
Equity investments often lead to conflicts between shareholders, directors, and companies.
- Shareholder Disputes
Disputes between shareholders can arise over dividend policies, business strategy, or use of company funds. When relationships break down, decisions can be paralysed, and the company itself can be jeopardised. We help clients enforce shareholder rights, negotiate settlements, and, when necessary, bring or defend legal claims. - Misrepresentation and Non-Disclosure
Investors sometimes discover that they were induced to invest by inaccurate statements or hidden risks. For example, a company may have overstated its financial health or failed to disclose existing liabilities. In such cases, we assess whether you have a claim for misrepresentation, advise on rescinding the investment, and pursue damages where appropriate. - Breach of Shareholders’ Agreements
Shareholders’ agreements and articles of association regulate how shares are transferred, how decisions are made, and what protections exist for minority investors. Breaches, such as failure to honour pre-emption rights or wrongful share allotments, are common grounds for disputes. We help enforce these agreements and secure remedies for breaches. - Minority Shareholder Protection
Minority shareholders can face exclusion from decision-making, unfair dilution of their shareholding, or diversion of company assets. Under the Companies Act 2006, unfair prejudice petitions allow minority shareholders to seek redress. We regularly bring such claims to secure remedies including buyouts at a fair value. - Director Misconduct and Breach of Fiduciary Duties
Directors owe legal duties to act in the best interests of the company. When they misuse funds, favour certain shareholders, or act in bad faith, investors may have claims against them. We provide advice on holding directors personally accountable.
2. Debt Investment Disputes
Debt-based investments often generate disputes around repayment obligations and security enforcement.
- Loan Defaults
A borrower’s failure to repay on time can trigger enforcement of guarantees, appointment of administrators, or winding-up petitions. We guide both creditors and debtors on enforcement and defence strategies. - Interest and Covenant Breaches
Disputes often centre on how interest is calculated or whether the borrower has breached financial covenants. We provide clear advice on interpreting loan documentation and enforcing or defending claims. - Convertible Loan Notes (CLNs)
CLNs are popular with investors seeking upside potential. However, disputes frequently occur over whether loans should convert to equity, at what valuation, and under what conditions. We assist in resolving these technical and often heated disagreements. - Guarantee Enforcement
Guarantees are a frequent source of conflict, especially where directors have given personal guarantees. We act for guarantors trying to limit exposure and for creditors seeking to enforce.
3. Cross-Over and Hybrid Disputes
- Exit Rights and Buyback Provisions
Investors may have rights to sell shares back to the company or to force an exit. Disagreements often centre on valuation methods or whether contractual conditions have been triggered. - Valuation Disputes
Whether relating to conversion of debt to equity, buyouts of minority shareholders, or enforcement of exit provisions, valuation is frequently contested. We collaborate with accountants and valuation experts to support robust arguments. - Fraud and Misappropriation of Funds
Sadly, some disputes involve fraudulent activity. Investors may discover that funds have been misused or directors have acted dishonestly. We provide guidance on fraud claims, breach of fiduciary duties, and recovery of assets.
Our Approach to Resolving Investment Disputes
- Early Case Assessment
We quickly assess your position and provide a realistic view of your chances of success. - Negotiation and Mediation
Many disputes can be resolved without litigation. We are skilled negotiators and use mediation to achieve settlements that protect your interests while saving costs. - Litigation and Arbitration
Where court or arbitration proceedings are unavoidable, we act decisively to advance or defend claims. - Commercially Practical Advice
We focus on the bigger picture. Protecting your reputation, preserving commercial relationships, and controlling costs are central to our advice.
Why Choose Jonathan Lea Network?
- Specialist Knowledge: Focused expertise in equity and debt investment disputes.
- Pragmatic and Commercial: Legal strategies aligned with commercial realities.
- Transparent Costs: Upfront guidance on fees and funding options.
- Tailored Service: Bespoke advice for SMEs, lenders, and individual investors.
Client Concerns We Address
- “How much of my investment can I realistically recover?”
- “Will pursuing this dispute damage my reputation?”
- “Do I need to prepare for a lengthy court battle?”
- “What happens if the company goes insolvent?”
We provide honest, commercially focused answers to these difficult questions, ensuring clients feel supported and prepared.
Investment Disputes FAQ
-
What remedies are available if I have been misled into making an investment?
-
You may be entitled to rescind the investment or claim damages for misrepresentation. The remedy depends on whether the misrepresentation was fraudulent, negligent, or innocent.
-
Can I stop directors from dissipating company assets while a dispute is ongoing?
-
Yes, the court can grant a freezing order to prevent directors from transferring or hiding assets.
-
What happens if a shareholders’ agreement conflicts with the company’s articles of association?
-
Courts usually enforce the shareholders’ agreement between the parties, while recognising the statutory effect of the articles. Conflicts often require litigation or negotiation to resolve.
-
Are derivative claims effective for investors?
-
Derivative claims allow shareholders to bring claims on behalf of the company, usually against directors. They are complex and require court permission but can be effective where wrongdoing has occurred and directors refuse to act.
-
Can an investor be forced to sell their shares against their will?
-
Yes, drag-along provisions can force minority shareholders to sell if the majority agree to a sale. Their enforceability depends on proper drafting and exercise.
-
How do courts determine “fair value” in shareholder buyouts?
-
Courts often rely on independent expert valuations and may exclude minority discounts, especially in unfair prejudice cases, to ensure fairness.
-
What are “deadlock” provisions and how do they affect disputes?
-
Deadlock provisions in shareholders’ agreements set out mechanisms to resolve stalemates, often by requiring one shareholder to buy the other out or triggering a third-party valuation. These provisions can help avoid prolonged litigation.
-
Can arbitration clauses limit my rights as an investor?
-
Yes, arbitration may exclude access to the courts. While arbitration is private and sometimes quicker, it can be costly and limit rights of appeal. Whether to agree depends on the investor’s objectives.
Take the Next Step
Investment disputes can escalate quickly and become highly damaging if not handled with expertise and urgency. By instructing the Jonathan Lea Network, you gain a trusted partner with deep experience in both equity and debt conflicts.
Contact us today to arrange a confidential consultation with one of our specialist solicitors. The earlier you seek advice, the more options you will have to secure the best possible outcome.
Phone: 01444 708640
Email: wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net
Photo by Arisa Chattasa on Unsplash
Our Investment Disputes Team
What Our Clients Say
Request a Free
No Obligation
20 Minute Call
This introductory call is to discuss your matter so we can provide a well-considered quote.
However, please be aware that the free 20 minute call is at our discretion. If you are more looking for advice and guidance on an initial call, we may instead offer a one-hour fixed fee appointment instead.
Our fixed fee appointments are between £200 – £300 + 20% VAT (£240 – £360 inclusive of VAT) depending on the seniority of the solicitor taking the call.