Separating Commercial Property from Your Trading Business
×
Separating commercial property - brick-and-steel engineering workshop on a Sussex business park, with open roller shutters, parked vans and autumn trees.

Separating Commercial Property from Your Trading Business

Kamana Rai is a qualified solicitor with experience advising founders, start-ups, and established companies on a broad range of corporate and commercial matters including equity fundraisings, mergers and acquisitions, corporate governance, and a wide range of commercial agreements across diverse sectors. 

A company that owns both its trading business and the premises from which it operates may eventually need to consider whether those assets should remain together, or whether separating commercial property from the trading business would work better.

This often becomes important when shareholders have different plans for retirement, succession, investment or a future business sale. One shareholder may want to continue operating the business, while another may wish to retain an interest in the premises and receive rental income. A business owner may also want to sell the trading operation while retaining the commercial property as a long-term investment.

Separating commercial property from a trading business can provide useful flexibility. It can also involve significant legal, tax, financing and practical issues. A property transfer should therefore be planned as part of a wider review of the company’s ownership, operations and future objectives.

This article explains why business owners may consider separating commercial property from their trading business and the issues to address before proceeding.

Why consider separating commercial property from a trading business?

Many owner-managed companies own the premises from which they trade. Over time, the property may become one of the company’s most valuable assets, alongside its contracts, employees, intellectual property, customer relationships and goodwill.

Keeping the property and trading business in one company can be straightforward for many years. Circumstances can change, however. A shareholder may wish to retire while another wants to continue running the business. The owners may want to pass the trading operation to the next generation while retaining the property. They may be considering a future business sale and want to retain the premises as an investment, with the purchaser taking a lease instead.

In some cases, shareholders simply recognise that the commercial property and trading business serve different purposes. The property may provide long-term rental income and capital value, while the trading company carries the risks and opportunities of the operating business.

Separating the two may make the ownership structure easier to understand and give shareholders more options for the future. It is important to recognise that moving commercial property to a different company is rarely a straightforward asset transfer. The property may represent a substantial proportion of the company’s overall value, and the transaction can have legal, tax, financing and accounting consequences.

What structure might be used for separating commercial property?

There is no single structure that works for every business.

A common arrangement involves transferring the commercial property to a separate property company. The trading company then occupies the premises under a commercial lease and pays rent to the property company.

A wider corporate reorganisation may be appropriate in other cases. This can involve a group structure, share transfers, new share issues or, where the relevant conditions are met, a demerger.

For example, a company may own a manufacturing business and the factory from which it operates. One shareholder may wish to retain and run the manufacturing business, while another may prefer to hold an interest in the factory and receive rental income. A carefully planned reorganisation may assist in separating those interests.

The desired end position should be agreed before documents are prepared. The legal mechanism should then be selected to support that commercial outcome.

A property separation is not automatically a statutory demerger. Depending on the circumstances, it may involve a property transfer, a group reorganisation, a share restructuring or a combination of these steps. Our practical guide to business demergers for owner-managed companies explains the wider restructuring routes that may be available where shareholders also wish to separate ownership.

Potential benefits of a separate property company

Clearer ownership arrangements

A separate property company can make it easier to distinguish between the assets used in the trade and the assets held as investments. This can be helpful where shareholders have different priorities. One may be focused on growing the trade, while another may be looking for longer-term income and capital value from the property.

Flexibility for succession and retirement

A family business may wish to transfer the trading operation to younger family members without transferring commercial property at the same time. Separating ownership of the trade and property can make it easier to consider different succession arrangements, subject to legal and tax advice.

Keeping the premises after a business sale

Business owners may want to sell the trading operation while retaining the premises. The property can then be leased to the buyer’s company. This may enable the former owners to receive rental income after the sale, provided that the lease terms are commercially acceptable to both the buyer and property owner.

Separating the property from the trading business

Some owners prefer to hold valuable commercial property separately from the trading company. This may help distinguish the investment asset from the operating business and make future ownership arrangements easier to manage.

A separate property company does not automatically protect the property from all trading risks or liabilities. Existing lending arrangements, cross-guarantees, intercompany obligations and personal guarantees may continue to create exposure. These arrangements should be reviewed before the structure is changed.

What happens to the trading company’s occupation after separating commercial property?

If the property is transferred to a separate company, the trading company will usually need a formal legal right to remain in occupation. This will often be dealt with through a commercial lease between the property company and the trading company.

The lease should reflect the intended commercial relationship and the owners’ plans for the future. The parties will need to consider the length of the term, rent, rent reviews, repair obligations, insurance, service charge, permitted use, alterations, assignment, subletting and break rights.

The parties should also consider security of tenure under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. In some circumstances, the lease may be contracted out of the statutory renewal provisions. This decision should be made carefully because it can affect the trading company’s future ability to remain in occupation.

Contracting out of the statutory renewal provisions requires a formal procedure before the lease is entered into. The parties should take advice before agreeing that arrangement because it may materially affect the trading company’s ability to remain in occupation at the end of the term.

The lease can also be important if the trading business is later sold. A buyer will often want confidence that the business can continue operating from the premises on secure and commercially workable terms. The property owner may, however, want to retain flexibility and protect the long-term value of the investment.

How should the property be valued?

Commercial property valuation can become a central issue where shareholders are separating their interests.

The relevant question is rarely limited to what the property originally cost. The shareholders may need to consider its current market value, market rent, outstanding borrowing, condition, planning position, development potential and any restrictions affecting title or use.

Existing leases, occupational arrangements, rights of way, easements, restrictive covenants and environmental matters may also affect value. If the property represents a substantial part of the company’s overall worth, an independent valuation may provide a useful basis for negotiations.

Valuation may be particularly important where shareholders are receiving different assets or interests as part of the transaction. It can help the parties assess whether the proposed division of value is fair and commercially sustainable.

The rent payable by the trading company should also be considered. It should be commercially justifiable and should reflect the property, the lease terms and the wider transaction structure.

Corporation Tax and capital gains issues when separating commercial property

Tax planning should take place before the structure is agreed and before the parties take any binding steps.

A company disposing of commercial property may be subject to Corporation Tax on any chargeable gain. This can be significant where the property has been owned for many years and has risen substantially in value.

The tax treatment will depend on the structure of the transaction, the relationship between the companies and whether the relevant statutory conditions are met. Where companies are members of the same qualifying capital gains group, an intra-group property transfer may generally take place on a no gain/no loss basis for Corporation Tax purposes.

This treatment should not be assumed. The group structure, the transaction steps and any planned future sale or ownership change need to be reviewed carefully. In particular, a later disposal of a company from the group can give rise to a degrouping charge in certain circumstances.

The transaction may also affect the tax position of individual shareholders. This is important where shareholders receive shares, cash, assets or other value as part of a reorganisation.

SDLT and Land Transaction Tax

SDLT can be payable when commercial property in England is transferred.

The SDLT treatment will depend on the detailed facts and transaction structure. Transfers involving connected companies can give rise to market-value rules, meaning that SDLT may be calculated by reference to the property’s market value even where little or no cash consideration is paid.

Reliefs may be available for certain qualifying group transfers, reconstructions or acquisitions. The conditions are detailed, and the availability of relief should be confirmed as part of the transaction planning. Later changes in ownership or control can also affect a relief claim.

If the property is in Wales, Land Transaction Tax will generally apply instead of SDLT. The Welsh rules and available reliefs should be reviewed separately.

SDLT or Land Transaction Tax should be considered at an early stage. A transaction that appears commercially attractive can become significantly more expensive if the property-tax consequences have not been identified before the structure is agreed.

VAT and the option to tax

VAT is another important consideration when transferring commercial property between companies.

Many commercial-property transactions are exempt from VAT. However, a seller may have exercised an option to tax the property. Where this has happened, VAT may be chargeable unless a relevant exemption or transfer-of-a-going-concern treatment applies.

Where a property-letting business is transferred, the transaction may potentially qualify as a transfer of a going concern. The conditions are specific and should be checked carefully. Where an opted property is involved, the receiving company may need to make and notify its own option to tax by the relevant date and provide the required confirmation to the seller.

The VAT treatment can affect cash flow, funding and the amount of VAT the receiving company can recover. Specialist tax advice should be obtained before contracts are exchanged or completion arrangements are finalised.

Mortgages, security and lender consent

A property transfer should be reviewed alongside the company’s financing arrangements.

The property may be subject to a legal charge, mortgage, debenture or other security. Shareholders may have given personal guarantees. The property may also support borrowing used by the trading company or another company within the group.

The lender may need to consent to the proposed transaction. Existing borrowing may need to be repaid, refinanced, transferred or replaced. The lender may require a new charge, additional guarantees or amendments to existing facilities.

Early discussions with lenders can prevent delays and help establish whether the desired structure is viable. This is particularly important where the property provides the principal security for the company’s borrowing.

What legal documents may be required for separating commercial property?

The documents required will depend on the transaction structure.

A property separation may involve company board minutes, shareholder resolutions, share transfers, share issues, a property transfer deed, Land Registry applications, lender-consent documents, releases or replacement guarantees and a new commercial lease.

The company’s articles of association and any shareholders’ agreement should be reviewed. They may contain restrictions on share transfers, consent requirements or provisions dealing with major transactions.

The property itself will also need appropriate legal due diligence. This may include reviewing title, charges, rights affecting the property, planning matters, environmental issues, existing leases and occupational arrangements.

If the property is leasehold, the lease may restrict assignment, charging, subletting or changes in control. Consent from a superior landlord may be required.

What if shareholders disagree about the property?

Commercial property can become a sensitive issue where shareholders are separating their interests, particularly where one shareholder regards the premises as essential to the trading business and another wishes to retain it as an investment.

Where the property question forms part of a wider shareholder disagreement, the appropriate solution may involve a broader shareholder separation or business divorce rather than a property transfer alone. Our guide to business divorce explains the issues that can arise when shareholders no longer want to work together.

Is separating commercial property always the right answer?

No. A separate property company can provide flexibility, but it can also create additional administration, professional fees, financing requirements and tax exposure.

The existing structure may already be appropriate. The property should be considered as part of the company’s wider commercial strategy, including any proposed sale, shareholder exit, retirement plan or succession arrangement.

When should business owners take advice?

Advice should be obtained before any property transfer, share issue, company incorporation or commitment to a particular structure.

The starting point is to establish the intended end position. The owners should consider who should own the trading business, who should own the property, whether the trading company will remain in occupation and whether the property should be retained after a future business sale.

It is also important to identify existing borrowing, lender security, shareholder guarantees and any consents required. The potential Corporation Tax, SDLT or Land Transaction Tax, VAT and shareholder-tax consequences should be assessed alongside the legal structure.

Accountants and tax advisers can advise on transaction taxes, reliefs and potential HMRC clearances. Solicitors can advise on the corporate structure, shareholder rights, property arrangements, leases, financing, due diligence and transaction documents.

Coordinating this advice early can help identify problems before shareholders commit to a particular transaction.

Related articles

How the Jonathan Lea Network can help with separating commercial property

Separating commercial property from a trading business requires careful planning and coordinated legal advice.

At Jonathan Lea Network, our corporate and commercial property lawyers can help business owners assess the proposed structure, identify the legal issues and prepare the documentation required to implement the transaction.

We can advise on corporate reorganisations, shareholder exits, business divorce issues, property transfers, commercial leases, lender consents, refinancing, shareholder agreements and preparations for a business sale. We can also work alongside your accountant or tax adviser so that legal, commercial and tax considerations are addressed together.

Early advice provides greater opportunity to compare possible structures, identify risks and avoid unexpected costs.

Frequently asked questions: separating commercial property

Can I transfer my business premises out of my trading company?

It may be possible, but the appropriate structure will depend on the company’s ownership, the property, its financing arrangements and the shareholders’ objectives. A transfer can have Corporation Tax, SDLT or Land Transaction Tax, VAT and other legal consequences, so advice should be obtained before proceeding.

Should a trading company own its commercial property?

There is no universal answer. Keeping the property and trading business in one company can be straightforward. Separating them may provide greater flexibility for succession planning, investment, shareholder exits or a future sale. The appropriate structure depends on the company’s circumstances and the owners’ objectives.

Can I put my business property into a separate company?

A company may be able to transfer commercial property to another company. The transfer needs to be structured carefully because connected-company rules can affect SDLT or Land Transaction Tax. Corporation Tax, VAT, lender-consent and lease issues may also arise.

Will I have to pay SDLT if I transfer commercial property between companies?

Possibly. The SDLT treatment depends on the transaction structure, whether the companies are connected and whether a statutory relief applies. Market-value rules can apply even where the amount paid is low. If the property is in Wales, Land Transaction Tax will generally apply instead.

Can a company demerge its property from its trading business?

Potentially. A company may separate property and trade through a range of structures, including a property transfer, group reorganisation or, where the relevant conditions are met, a statutory demerger. The most suitable route depends on the ownership structure, property, funding, tax position and shareholders’ objectives.

Will VAT apply if my company transfers commercial property to another company?

It may. The VAT position depends on the property, whether an option to tax has been made and whether the transaction qualifies as a transfer of a going concern. VAT advice should be obtained before the transaction is documented or completed.

Can I keep the property after selling my trading business?

In some circumstances, yes. The property may be held in a separate company and leased to the buyer’s trading company. This can allow the owners to retain the property and receive rent after the business sale. The lease terms, financing arrangements, tax consequences and buyer requirements will need careful consideration.

Should I separate the property before selling my business?

It depends. Separating the property before a sale may be suitable where the owners want to retain the premises as an investment. It can also create additional legal, tax and financing consequences. The proposed sale structure, buyer expectations and commercial objectives should be reviewed before deciding whether a separation is worthwhile.

Do I need my accountant as well as a solicitor?

Often, yes. A solicitor can advise on the corporate, property and legal mechanics. An accountant or tax adviser can assess Corporation Tax, SDLT, Land Transaction Tax, VAT, shareholder-tax consequences, reliefs and any relevant HMRC clearance. Early coordination can help ensure that the structure works in practice.

How long does it take to separate commercial property from a trading company?

There is no standard timescale. The process can depend on the corporate structure, property title, lender requirements, tax advice, shareholder negotiations, valuation, HMRC clearance where relevant and the complexity of the transaction documents. A transaction involving valuable commercial property should be planned well in advance.

Contact us

We provide most enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate, based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.

In the same email you will be invited to arrange a 20-minute complimentary, no-obligation video consultation, should the proposed scope of work and fee estimate be of interest. This initial discussion is designed to better understand your requirements, refine the scope and ensure our approach is fully aligned with your objectives, at the end of which we will email you a definitive formal fee estimate to consider and approve.

Where you would prefer to receive initial advice and guidance from the outset, or where a short introductory call would not be the most appropriate starting point, we may instead recommend a 2.5-hour fixed-fee appointment, starting from £700 + VAT. This enables us to review the information you provide, discuss your situation with you and provide considered, tailored advice at an early stage.

To make an enquiry, please email us at wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net, complete our contact form, or call us on 01444 708640.

VAT is charged at 20%.

This article is intended for general information only, applies to the law at the time of publication, is not specific to the facts of your case and is not intended to be a replacement for legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before relying on any of the information given. © Jonathan Lea Limited.

Kamana Rai is a qualified solicitor with experience advising founders, start-ups, and established companies on a broad range of corporate and commercial matters including equity fundraisings, mergers and acquisitions, corporate governance, and a wide range of commercial agreements across diverse sectors. 

About Kamana Rai

Kamana Rai is a qualified solicitor with experience advising founders, start-ups, and established companies on a broad range of corporate and commercial matters including equity fundraisings, mergers and acquisitions, corporate governance, and a wide range of commercial agreements across diverse sectors.

The Jonathan Lea Network is now a full service firm of solicitors that employs senior and junior solicitors, trainee solicitors, paralegals and administration staff who all work from a modern open plan office in Haywards Heath. This close-knit retained team is enhanced by a trusted network of specialist consultant solicitors who work remotely and, where relevant, combine seamlessly with the central team.

If you’d like a competitive quote for any legal work please first complete our contact form, or send an email to wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net with an introduction and an overview of the issues you’d like to discuss. Someone will then liaise to fix a mutually convenient time for either a no obligation discovery call with one of our solicitors (following which a quote can be provided), or if you are instead looking for advice and guidance from the outset we may offer a one-hour fixed fee appointment in place of the discovery call.

We are always keen to take on new work and ensure that clients will not only come back to us again, but also recommend us to others too.

×
Get In Touch

Contact Us

In need of legal guidance? How can we help?

We provide enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate and offer a complimentary 20 minute phone or video call based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.

Name(Required)