Unfair Prejudice Claims | JLN Solicitors
×
Have you been pushed out of decisions about a company you helped build? Perhaps other shareholders are taking money out of the business, excluding you from management or making decisions that threaten the value of your investment. If you feel that your interests are being unfairly ignored, you may have grounds to take action. Our solicitors advise shareholders on unfair prejudice claims, helping them protect their position and pursue a fair outcome.Being treated unfairly by people you’ve worked alongside or trusted can be particularly difficult. You may have invested years of work and substantial money into the business, only to find yourself excluded, financially disadvantaged or unable to leave on reasonable terms. You might also be concerned about the cost of challenging the situation and whether doing so will make relationships worse.

At Jonathan Lea Network, we understand that you want to regain some control over your circumstances. Whether your priority is securing a fair price for your shares, stopping harmful conduct or finding a way to move on, we can help you understand your rights and the options available. Our approach is practical, commercially focused and designed to achieve a proportionate resolution wherever possible.

What Is an Unfair Prejudice Claim?

An unfair prejudice claim allows a shareholder to ask the court for protection where a company’s affairs are being managed in a way that unfairly harms their interests as a shareholder.

These claims are brought under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006.

The law recognises that shareholders, particularly those with smaller holdings, can sometimes find themselves in a difficult position when other shareholders control the company.

However, not every disagreement or disappointing business decision will justify a claim.

To establish unfair prejudice, the shareholder must show that the relevant conduct has caused, or would cause, prejudice to their interests as a shareholder and that the prejudice is unfair.

What does this mean in practice?

You might have grounds for a claim if other shareholders have improperly excluded you from management, diverted company funds for their own benefit or deliberately reduced your shareholding.

The circumstances matter. We assess what was agreed between the shareholders, how the company has historically operated and whether the conduct has crossed the legal threshold.

When Can You Bring an Unfair Prejudice Claim?

You may be able to bring a claim where the company’s affairs have been conducted unfairly, or where an actual or proposed company decision would unfairly harm your interests.

There are several situations in which this might arise.

You’ve been excluded from running the company

Perhaps you helped establish the business on the understanding that you would be involved in managing it, but the other shareholders have now removed you from decision-making.

Exclusion from management is not automatically unfair prejudice. However, it may support a claim where your participation formed part of the agreement or understanding between the shareholders and the exclusion is unjustified.

Company money is being used improperly

You may discover that company funds are being used for personal expenses, that directors are receiving unjustified benefits or that business opportunities are being diverted elsewhere.

Such conduct may harm the company and, in certain circumstances, unfairly prejudice shareholders.

We can investigate whether the conduct supports an unfair prejudice claim or whether another type of legal action would be more appropriate.

Your shareholding has been unfairly diluted

If a company issues additional shares, your percentage ownership may decrease.

This is not necessarily unlawful. However, issuing shares for an improper purpose, such as deliberately weakening your voting power or benefiting the majority at your expense, may provide grounds for a challenge.

Agreements between shareholders have been disregarded

Your shareholders’ agreement or the company’s articles of association may protect your rights to participate in decisions or require certain procedures to be followed.

A serious breach of these arrangements may contribute to an unfair prejudice claim, particularly where it causes real harm to your interests as a shareholder.

Can You Claim Unfair Prejudice If You’ve Been Forced Out of Your Business?

Being excluded from a business you’ve helped establish can be particularly distressing, especially if you remain a shareholder but no longer have any meaningful involvement.

You may feel that the other shareholders have taken control of something you helped create.

When exclusion from management may be unfair

In some owner-managed companies, shareholders establish the business on the understanding that they will all participate in management.

This type of arrangement may be relevant even where the company’s formal documents do not record every aspect of the shareholders’ understanding.

If one shareholder is later excluded without proper justification, that exclusion may amount to unfair prejudice.

However, the court will consider the circumstances, including whether the exclusion was justified by the shareholder’s conduct.

What if you’re also a director?

Your position as a director is legally separate from your position as a shareholder.

Removing you from the board does not automatically mean your shareholder rights have been breached. Nevertheless, the removal may be relevant to an unfair prejudice claim where your involvement in management formed part of the basis on which you became or remained a shareholder.

We can assess both aspects of your position and advise on the appropriate remedies.

What Can You Achieve Through an Unfair Prejudice Claim?

If an unfair prejudice claim succeeds, the court has wide powers to make orders designed to address the unfair treatment.

The available remedies are set out in section 996 of the Companies Act 2006.

The court will consider what is appropriate in the circumstances rather than automatically granting the remedy requested.

A court-ordered share buyout

One of the most common outcomes is an order requiring another shareholder to purchase your shares.

This can allow you to leave the company and receive a price determined on a fair basis.

For shareholders who can no longer work with their business partners, a buyout may offer a practical way to bring the relationship to an end.

Orders addressing the company’s conduct

The court may also make orders regulating how the company is managed in the future.

For example, it may require the company to stop particular conduct or take steps to address matters that have been unfairly neglected.

Other remedies

Depending on the circumstances, the court may authorise proceedings on behalf of the company or grant other appropriate relief, which can include monetary compensation.

However, successful proceedings do not guarantee a particular outcome. We will help you assess which remedy is realistic and commercially worthwhile before deciding whether to proceed.

How Is the Value of Your Shares Decided in an Unfair Prejudice Claim?

If the court orders another shareholder to buy your shares, agreeing the purchase price can become one of the most important parts of the case.

You will naturally want the valuation to reflect the value of your investment and avoid rewarding the conduct that led to the dispute.

How the court approaches valuation

The court has considerable discretion when deciding how shares should be valued.

It may consider the company’s financial performance, the appropriate valuation date and whether any unfair conduct has affected the value of the business.

Independent valuation evidence is often required.

Will your shares be discounted because you’re a minority shareholder?

A minority discount is not automatic.

In some unfair prejudice cases, particularly where shareholders established a business on the understanding that they would participate together in its management, the court may consider a valuation without a minority discount appropriate.

However, the correct approach depends on the facts, and a discount may still be justified in some circumstances.

Our solicitors can work with valuation experts to help you understand the financial implications of a potential buyout.

For more detailed guidance on how company shares are valued, see our article on private company valuations for shareholder buyouts.

Do You Have to Go to Court to Resolve an Unfair Prejudice Dispute?

No. Even where you have grounds for an unfair prejudice claim, going to court may not be the best or only way to achieve your objectives.

Proceedings can be costly, time-consuming and disruptive, particularly where the shareholders are still involved in running the business.

We consider whether the dispute can be resolved through negotiation or another appropriate process before recommending litigation.

Negotiating a settlement

A negotiated agreement may allow the parties to resolve the dispute without the uncertainty of a court judgment.

For example, the other shareholders may agree to purchase your shares, change the company’s management arrangements or address specific concerns.

We can help negotiate the terms and ensure the agreement is properly documented.

Mediation

Mediation involves an independent mediator helping the parties explore a mutually acceptable resolution.

It can be particularly useful where relationships have deteriorated but both sides recognise the financial and commercial benefits of avoiding court proceedings.

When court proceedings may be necessary

Sometimes the other shareholders will not engage, deny that anything improper has happened or refuse to offer reasonable terms.

In these circumstances, bringing an unfair prejudice petition may be appropriate.

We can assess the strength of your case, explain the potential outcomes and advise on the costs and risks before proceedings begin.

What Evidence Do You Need for an Unfair Prejudice Claim?

Strong evidence is important because an unfair prejudice claim usually involves examining what happened within the company and whether the conduct was unfair in the context of the shareholders’ relationship.

The documents and information required will depend on the allegations.

Relevant evidence may include:

  • Company agreements and records. The articles of association and shareholders’ agreement can establish the formal rights of each shareholder. Meeting minutes and company records may also help show how decisions were made.
  • Emails and other communications. Correspondence may demonstrate what the shareholders agreed, how they expected the business to operate and whether those arrangements later changed. We can help identify which communications are relevant.
  • Financial information. Company accounts, transaction records and other financial documents may help establish whether funds have been misused or value has been diverted. Access to these documents must be obtained through lawful means.
  • Evidence of exclusion or unfair treatment. Records of meetings, changes in responsibilities or decisions taken without your involvement may help establish the history of the dispute. The surrounding circumstances will also need to be considered.

You do not need to have every document before seeking legal advice.

We can help identify what evidence is required, which information you are entitled to access and whether formal disclosure may be needed.

Can an Unfair Prejudice Claim Be Defended?

Yes. If you are a shareholder, director or other respondent facing an unfair prejudice petition, you may have grounds to dispute the allegations or challenge the remedy being sought.

Being accused of unfair conduct does not mean the claim will succeed.

Challenging the allegations

You may be able to demonstrate that the relevant decisions were properly authorised, commercially justified or consistent with the company’s agreements.

For example, excluding a shareholder from management may be justified in circumstances involving serious misconduct or other legitimate concerns.

Responding to a proposed share buyout

Even if there is merit in some of the allegations, the parties may disagree about whether a buyout is appropriate or what price should be paid.

We can help respondents assess the claim, protect their position and consider whether a negotiated settlement would be preferable.

Managing the commercial impact

Defending an unfair prejudice claim can place pressure on the company’s management, finances and reputation.

We focus on developing a proportionate response that addresses the legal issues while considering the continued operation of the business.

Our director and shareholder dispute solicitors advise both parties bringing claims and those responding to shareholder disputes.

Why Is It Important to Get Advice Early?

If you believe you are being treated unfairly, getting advice early can help you understand your position and avoid making the situation more difficult.

It may also help preserve evidence and identify opportunities to resolve the disagreement before positions become entrenched.

Avoid decisions that weaken your position

Resigning as a director, accepting a low share valuation or signing an agreement without advice could have lasting consequences.

We can help you understand the implications before you commit to a course of action.

Understand whether you have a viable claim

Not every act of unfair treatment meets the legal requirements for unfair prejudice.

An early review can help distinguish a potentially strong claim from a disagreement that may be better addressed through negotiation or another legal remedy.

Consider timing and delay

The Supreme Court confirmed in February 2026, in THG Plc v Zedra Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd [2026] UKSC 6, that there is no statutory limitation period under the Limitation Act 1980 for an unfair prejudice petition under section 994.

However, this does not mean it is sensible to delay. The court may consider delay, prejudice caused by delay and whether a shareholder has accepted or acquiesced in the conduct when deciding what relief, if any, to grant.

Other related claims may also be subject to statutory time limits.

We can advise on the appropriate timing and any urgent steps needed to protect your position.

Why Choose Jonathan Lea Network for Unfair Prejudice Claims?

An unfair prejudice claim can involve complex legal issues, financial disagreements and difficult relationships between people who may have worked together for many years.

At Jonathan Lea Network, we combine dispute resolution experience with commercial and corporate legal expertise to provide advice that considers the bigger picture.

We understand the commercial pressures

We recognise that a shareholder dispute can affect your investment, income and future plans.

Our starting point is to understand what you want to achieve and identify an approach that reflects your commercial priorities.

We provide joined-up advice

Unfair prejudice claims often overlap with shareholder agreements, director responsibilities, company valuations and potential share buyouts.

Our corporate and dispute resolution teams can work together to address these connected issues, reducing the risk of important matters being overlooked.

We focus on proportionate solutions

We know that litigation can be expensive and uncertain.

Where appropriate, we explore settlement options and negotiated buyouts before recommending formal proceedings.

If court action is necessary, we can help you prepare your case and pursue or defend the claim with a clear understanding of the risks involved.

Our solicitors advise clients in Sussex and across England and Wales, providing straightforward, practical support during shareholder disputes.

What Is the Process for Bringing an Unfair Prejudice Claim?

Every case is different, but we aim to provide a clear strategy and explain the steps involved from the outset.

  1. Understanding your circumstances

We begin by discussing the alleged unfair treatment, your involvement in the company and what you want to achieve.

We consider whether there are immediate concerns requiring attention and whether an unfair prejudice claim is likely to be appropriate.

  1. Reviewing the evidence and assessing your legal position

We examine the relevant agreements, company records, correspondence and available financial information.

We then advise on the potential strengths and weaknesses of your position, the available remedies and the likely financial implications.

  1. Exploring a negotiated resolution

Where appropriate, we may recommend raising the concerns formally, making a settlement proposal or attempting mediation.

A negotiated buyout or other agreement may achieve your objectives without the cost and uncertainty of proceedings.

  1. Preparing and pursuing court proceedings

If litigation is appropriate, we can help prepare the petition and supporting evidence, work with specialist counsel and financial experts, and manage the proceedings.

We will continue to consider opportunities for settlement as the case progresses.

How Long Do Unfair Prejudice Claims Take and What Will They Cost?

The time and cost involved depend on the complexity of the dispute, the number of parties and whether the claim can be resolved through negotiation.

Some disagreements can be settled without proceedings. More complex cases may involve extensive financial evidence, disputed factual issues and a contested court hearing.

These proceedings can become expensive, particularly where the value of the company or the history of the shareholders’ relationship is disputed.

We aim to provide a realistic assessment of the options and likely costs at an early stage.

Our fees will depend on the scope of work required. We will explain our proposed approach and provide an estimate before you decide whether to proceed.

Where appropriate, we may recommend an initial assessment of the claim before committing to a wider litigation strategy.

Contact Us

We provide most enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate, based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.

In the same email you will be invited to arrange a 20-minute complimentary, no-obligation video consultation, should the proposed scope of work and fee estimate be of interest. This initial discussion is designed to better understand your requirements, refine the scope and ensure our approach is fully aligned with your objectives, at the end of which we will email you a definitive formal fee estimate to consider and approve.

Where you would prefer to receive initial advice and guidance from the outset, or where a short introductory call would not be the most appropriate starting point, we may instead recommend a 2.5-hour fixed-fee appointment, starting from £750 + VAT. This enables us to review the information you provide, discuss your situation with you and provide considered, tailored advice at an early stage.

To make an enquiry, please email us at wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net, complete our contact form, or call us on 01444 708640.

VAT is charged at 20%.

This page is intended for general information only, applies to the law at the time of publication, is not specific to the facts of your case and is not intended to be a replacement for legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before relying on any of the information given. © Jonathan Lea Limited.

Frequently Asked Questions About Unfair Prejudice Claims

Can I bring an unfair prejudice claim if I own only a small percentage of the company?

Yes. There is no general minimum percentage shareholding required to bring a claim under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006. However, you must have the necessary legal standing and show that the relevant conduct is unfairly prejudicial to your interests as a shareholder. The size of your holding may affect the commercial value of the claim and the remedies sought.

Can I bring an unfair prejudice claim if I am no longer a director?

Yes, provided you have the necessary standing as a shareholder or otherwise fall within the statutory provisions. An unfair prejudice claim concerns your interests as a company member, not simply your position as a director. Your removal from management may nevertheless be relevant, depending on the agreements and understandings between the shareholders.

Can I bring a claim if the company is still profitable?

Yes. A profitable company can still be managed in a way that unfairly harms a shareholder’s interests. For example, there may be concerns about improper financial benefits, exclusion from management or unfair dilution of shares. The question is whether the relevant conduct satisfies the statutory requirements, not whether the company is making a profit.

Can the court force another shareholder to buy my shares?

Yes. If an unfair prejudice petition succeeds, the court may order another shareholder or the company to purchase your shares. This is a common remedy where the relationship between shareholders has broken down. However, a buyout is not guaranteed, and the court will determine the appropriate remedy based on the circumstances.

Will I receive the full value of my shares if I win?

Not necessarily. If a buyout is ordered, the court will determine what valuation approach is fair in the circumstances. This may involve considering the valuation date, company performance and whether any minority discount should apply. Specialist valuation evidence may be required, and the outcome will depend on the particular facts.

How long do I have to bring an unfair prejudice claim?

The Supreme Court confirmed in February 2026 that no statutory limitation period under the Limitation Act 1980 applies to section 994 petitions. However, delaying may still prejudice your case or affect the relief available, particularly where evidence is lost or your conduct suggests acceptance of the situation. Other related claims may have different deadlines, so early advice remains important.

Can I bring an unfair prejudice claim without going to court?

An unfair prejudice petition is a court procedure, so a formal claim must be brought before the court. However, you may be able to resolve the underlying dispute without issuing proceedings. Negotiation, mediation or an agreed shareholder buyout can sometimes achieve a suitable outcome without the time and cost of litigation.

What happens if I lose an unfair prejudice claim?

If your claim fails, you may be responsible for your own legal costs and may also be ordered to pay some or all of the other parties’ costs. The financial consequences can be significant, particularly in complex proceedings involving expert evidence. We can help assess the merits and costs risks before you decide whether to pursue a claim.

Take Action Today

Whether you are defending your position, bringing a claim against another director, or seeking to understand your obligations, it is vital to act promptly. Delay can limit your options, increase costs, and worsen the impact on your business.

Call+44 (0)1444 708 640 to arrange a free initial consultation.

Or use our simple online enquiry form and one of our expert solicitors will be in touch.

Please do get in touch with us so that we can utilise our expertise to steer you to the most suitable outcome.

Our Partnership Disputes Team

What Our Clients Say

Google rating score: 4.9 / 5, based on 99 reviews

Request a Free No Obligation 20 Minute Call

We provide most enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate, based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.

In the same email you will be invited to arrange a 20-minute complimentary, no-obligation video consultation, should the proposed scope of work and fee estimate be of interest. This initial discussion is designed to better understand your requirements, refine the scope and ensure our approach is fully aligned with your objectives, at the end of which we will email you a definitive formal fee estimate to consider and approve.

Where you would prefer to receive initial advice and guidance from the outset, or where a short introductory call would not be the most appropriate starting point, we may instead recommend a 2.5-hour fixed-fee appointment, starting from £750 + VAT. This enables us to review the information you provide, discuss your situation with you and provide considered, tailored advice at an early stage.

To make an enquiry, please email us at wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net, complete the form or call us on 01444 708640.

Name(Required)
×
Get In Touch

Contact Us

In need of legal guidance? How can we help?

We provide enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate and offer a complimentary 20 minute phone or video call based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.

Name(Required)