
Restrictive Covenants in Dental Practice Sale Agreements: Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation Clauses Explained

Why do restrictive covenants in dental practice sales matter?
They protect the goodwill the buyer is paying for
When a buyer acquires a dental practice, a significant part of the purchase price is often attributed to goodwill, which is why restrictive covenants in dental practice sales matter. Goodwill is the value of the practice beyond its physical assets, including patient relationships, local reputation, referral sources, recurring income, brand, staff stability and the likelihood that patients will continue attending after completion.
Restrictive covenants are contractual promises that restrict what the seller can do after completion. In a dental practice sale, they are commonly used to stop the seller from immediately competing with the practice, soliciting patients, poaching staff or undermining the goodwill that has just been sold.
For buyers, these clauses can be critical. Without an enforceable express non-compete restriction, a seller may generally be able to open or join a competing practice nearby. Where the seller has sold the business’s goodwill, the law may already restrict active solicitation of former patients, but the position depends on the transaction structure and terms. Express, properly tailored covenants remain important because they define the protection being agreed.
For sellers, restrictive covenants are equally important. A seller may be willing to protect the buyer’s goodwill, but should not accept restrictions that unnecessarily prevent them earning a living, continuing a clinical career, or working outside the genuine scope of the practice being sold.
Buyer and seller should discuss restrictive covenants early, ideally at heads of terms stage. If they are first raised late in the drafting process, they can become a source of tension and delay.
For wider context, see JLN’s main guide to Buying or Selling a Dental Practice.
What types of restrictive covenant are used in dental practice sales?
Different restrictions protect different parts of the business
Restrictive covenants are not all the same. A well-drafted sale agreement will usually use different clauses to protect different risks.
The main types include:
- Non-compete clauses. These restrict the seller from being involved in a competing dental practice for a defined period and within a defined area. They are usually the most sensitive type of restriction because they directly limit what the seller can do after completion.
- Non-solicitation clauses. These prevent the seller from approaching or encouraging patients, referral sources, staff, associates or suppliers to move away from the sold practice. They are often easier to justify than a broad non-compete because they target active interference rather than all competing activity.
- Non-dealing clauses. These may prevent the seller from dealing with certain patients or contacts, even if the patient or contact approaches the seller first. They can be powerful, but should be carefully tailored because they may restrict passive as well as active conduct.
- Staff and associate protection clauses. These prevent the seller from recruiting or encouraging employees, associates, hygienists or key team members to leave the practice. They can be important where value depends on a stable clinical and administrative team.
- Confidentiality obligations. These protect information such as patient lists, pricing, referral relationships, business plans, supplier terms and internal systems. Confidentiality clauses often sit alongside restrictive covenants and may continue for longer.
Are restrictive covenants in dental practice sales enforceable?
They must be reasonable and protect a legitimate interest
Under English law, restrictive covenants are not automatically enforceable just because they appear in a signed agreement. A clause that restrains trade is generally unenforceable unless the party seeking to enforce it can show that it protects a legitimate business interest, goes no further than reasonably necessary, and is not contrary to the public interest.
In a dental practice sale, legitimate interests may include goodwill, patient relationships, confidential information, referral networks, staff stability and the value of the business transferred to the buyer.
The courts generally treat restrictions in a business sale differently from restrictions in an ordinary employment contract. A seller who receives payment for goodwill may be expected to accept more substantial restrictions than an employee leaving a job. However, that does not mean anything goes. The restriction must still be properly targeted and, where relevant, considered under competition law. A restriction that is directly related and necessary to implementing the acquisition may be more defensible, but its duration, geography and activities should still be justified.
Reasonableness will usually depend on factors such as duration, geography, scope of restricted activities, the seller’s role before completion, the type of practice, the patient base and the price paid for goodwill.
What should a non-compete clause cover?
The clause should match the actual competitive risk
A non-compete clause is designed to prevent the seller from competing with the practice after completion. In dental practice sales, this may include restrictions on owning, operating, managing, being employed by or providing services to a competing practice.
The parties should draft the clause with care. A buyer may want broad protection, but a clause that is too broad can be more vulnerable to challenge. The stronger approach is to identify the real commercial risk and draft around it.
Key points include:
- The restricted area. A local general dental practice may justify a restriction around the practice’s catchment area, but the appropriate radius will depend on the location and patient base. A city-centre practice, rural practice and specialist referral practice may require different approaches.
- The restricted period. The duration should be long enough to protect the buyer’s goodwill and support the patient transition, but not longer than reasonably necessary. What is reasonable will depend on the seller’s importance to the practice and the level of goodwill being acquired.
- The restricted activities. The clause should focus on activities that compete with the practice being sold. If the practice provides general dentistry only, a restriction on unrelated healthcare work will ordinarily be difficult to justify unless there is a clear legitimate interest.
- The seller’s future career. A seller may want to continue clinical work, teach, consult, work outside the area, or provide services that do not compete with the sold practice. The parties should consider these carve-outs before signing.
A buyer should avoid simply asking for the broadest possible wording. A well-targeted clause is often more commercially effective and easier to defend.
How do non-solicitation clauses protect patients and referral relationships?
They prevent the seller from actively pulling goodwill away
Non-solicitation clauses are particularly important because patient relationships and referral sources may be central to value.
A patient non-solicitation clause usually prevents the seller from contacting or encouraging patients of the sold practice to move to another practice. It may also cover referral sources, such as local clinicians, specialists, care providers or other professional contacts.
The wording should make clear who it protects. It may cover patients who attended during a defined period before completion, active patients, plan patients, referral contacts or other identifiable groups. Overly broad wording can create uncertainty and may be harder to justify.
Non-solicitation clauses should also address indirect solicitation. For example, a seller should not be able to avoid the restriction by asking a colleague, new employer or connected business to approach patients on their behalf.
At the same time, the clause should not be drafted so broadly that it captures ordinary public marketing with no real connection to the sold practice. A general website or advert may be different from directly contacting known patients of the practice.
How do staff and associate restrictions work?
The clinical team may be part of the goodwill being protected
A dental practice’s goodwill is often tied to its team. Associates, hygienists, nurses, reception staff and practice managers may have strong patient relationships and operational knowledge.
A buyer may therefore seek restrictions preventing the seller from soliciting key staff or associates, and in some cases from recruiting, employing or engaging them. These restrictions should be limited to what is necessary and proportionate to protect the value transferred through the acquisition. The parties should not assume that a general no-hire arrangement between businesses is lawful merely because a sale agreement includes it.
The clause should identify which people it protects. It may cover employees, workers, associates, hygienists, consultants and contractors who worked at the practice before completion. It should also specify the relevant period and whether it applies only to people with whom the seller had material dealings.
The parties should coordinate staff and associate restrictions with employment law, TUPE obligations and associate agreements. A covenant in the sale agreement is only one part of the wider staffing and continuity picture.
What should sellers check before agreeing restrictive covenants?
A seller should understand the practical impact before signing
Restrictive covenants can have a significant impact on what the seller can do after completion. This is particularly important where the seller wants to continue working as a dentist, set up elsewhere, join another practice, or retain some involvement in the sector.
Before agreeing covenants, sellers should consider:
- Future work. If the seller has already agreed a future role, they should check the covenants against that plan. A restriction that conflicts with the seller’s intended work can create immediate risk.
- Geography and duration. A restriction should reflect the practice’s real patient catchment and competitive area. Sellers should be cautious about broad regional restrictions or periods that last longer than necessary to protect goodwill.
- Necessary exceptions. A seller may need carve-outs for non-clinical work, teaching, consultancy, emergency work, work outside the area, existing investments, or services that do not compete with the practice.
- Connected parties. A clause may restrict the seller from acting through a company, family member or business partner, or require the seller to procure specified conduct by an entity they control. A connected person is not automatically bound merely because of that connection, so a buyer may need a separate covenant if they require direct obligations.
Restrictive covenants are much easier to negotiate before signing than after completion. Sellers should take advice before agreeing heads of terms if these clauses are likely to be commercially important.
What should buyers do to improve enforceability?
Buyers should draft for the risk they can justify
A buyer’s objective should not be to include the longest and widest covenant possible. The objective should be to protect the value being acquired in a way that is commercially realistic and legally defensible.
Useful steps include:
- Identify the goodwill being protected. The buyer should be able to explain why the restriction is needed. This may include the seller’s patient relationships, referral contacts, local reputation or influence over associates and staff.
- Tailor the clause to the practice. A specialist referral practice, multi-site group, rural practice and high-street private practice may each need different wording. Template clauses can miss important details or go too far.
- Use separate restrictions for separate risks. A narrow non-solicitation clause, a targeted staff-poaching restriction and a carefully drafted non-compete may work better than one broad clause trying to cover everything.
- Avoid overreach. If a covenant prevents too much activity for too long or across too wide an area, the buyer may find that the protection is weaker than expected.
Buyers should also ensure that restrictive covenants sit alongside other protections, including handover obligations, transfer of digital assets, confidentiality clauses, associate retention planning and deferred consideration provisions where appropriate.
What happens if a restrictive covenant is breached?
The buyer may need to act quickly
If a buyer believes the seller has breached a restrictive covenant, speed can matter. Delay may make it harder to protect the practice’s goodwill, particularly if patients, staff or referral contacts are already moving.
Potential remedies may include an injunction, damages or other contractual remedies. An injunction is a court order requiring someone to stop doing something or, in some cases, to take specific steps. Damages are financial compensation for loss.
Before taking action, the buyer should gather evidence carefully. This may include patient communications, marketing materials, website screenshots, social media posts, staff approaches, referral records, correspondence and evidence of lost business.
The buyer should also review the covenant wording. The fact that the seller is working elsewhere does not necessarily mean there has been a breach. The question is what the clause prohibits and whether the seller’s conduct falls within it.
Sellers should take allegations of breach seriously. Even if the seller believes the clause is unenforceable or has not been breached, the dispute can become urgent and costly. Early advice can help assess risk and explore resolution.
How should heads of terms address restrictive covenants in dental practice sales?
The main restrictions should be agreed early
The parties should not leave restrictive covenants until the final draft of the sale agreement. They affect the commercial bargain and may influence price, handover and the seller’s future plans.
Heads of terms should usually identify whether the seller will give non-compete, non-solicitation, non-dealing, staff non-poaching and confidentiality obligations. They should also set out the proposed duration, restricted area and any obvious carve-outs.
The heads of terms do not need full legal drafting, but they should make the commercial position clear enough that neither party is surprised later.
For example, if the buyer expects a two-year local non-compete, they should raise it at heads of terms stage. If the seller wants to continue working elsewhere, they should also address that early.
How the Jonathan Lea Network can help with restrictive covenants in dental practice sales
We help buyers protect goodwill and sellers avoid unnecessary restrictions
At The Jonathan Lea Network, we advise buyers, sellers, dentists, associates and dental groups on dental practice sales and acquisitions across England and Wales. We understand that restrictive covenants are not just legal boilerplate. They can directly affect goodwill, price, handover, patient retention and the seller’s future career.
For buyers, we can help identify what goodwill needs protecting, draft proportionate non-compete and non-solicitation clauses, negotiate staff and associate protections, and advise on enforcement if a covenant is breached.
For sellers, we can help review proposed restrictions, negotiate appropriate limits and carve-outs, assess whether clauses are commercially workable, and reduce the risk of signing obligations that go further than necessary.
We can also coordinate restrictive covenant advice with the wider transaction, including heads of terms, due diligence, goodwill protection, associate agreements, deferred consideration and completion planning.
For broader context, see our main guide to Buying or Selling a Dental Practice.
Speak to JLN before agreeing non-compete or non-solicitation wording
The right wording can protect value and reduce dispute risk
If you are buying or selling a dental practice, you should consider restrictive covenants before the sale agreement is nearly complete. The buyer needs protection for the goodwill being acquired, and the seller needs clarity about what they can do after completion.
JLN can help you agree restrictions that are commercially clear, legally proportionate and tailored to the dental practice being sold.
Contact The Jonathan Lea Network to discuss restrictive covenants in a proposed dental practice sale or acquisition.
Frequently asked questions: restrictive covenants in dental practice sales
It is a contractual promise that limits what the seller can do after completion. Restrictive covenants in dental practice sales protect the goodwill the buyer has just paid for. They usually stop the seller competing straight away, approaching patients or poaching staff. A sale agreement often uses several clauses for different risks. These include non-compete, non-solicitation, non-dealing and confidentiality obligations. Discuss them early, ideally when you agree heads of terms. Restrictive covenants in dental practice sales can be enforceable, but not automatically. Under English law, a clause that restrains trade is generally unenforceable unless three tests are met. It must protect a legitimate business interest and go no further than reasonably necessary. It must also not be against the public interest. In a dental practice sale, goodwill, patient relationships and referral networks can be legitimate interests. A well-targeted clause is often easier to defend than a broad one. Take advice on the wording before you sign. There is no set period. The restriction should last long enough to protect the buyer’s goodwill and support the patient transition. However, it should last no longer than reasonably necessary. What is reasonable depends on the seller’s importance to the practice. It also depends on how much goodwill the buyer is acquiring. If the buyer expects a particular period, such as a two-year local non-compete, raise it at heads of terms stage. That way, neither side gets a surprise later. It depends on the practice. A local general dental practice may justify a restriction around its catchment area. However, the right radius depends on the location and the patient base. A city-centre practice, a rural practice and a specialist referral practice may each need a different approach. The restricted area should reflect the practice’s real patient catchment and competitive area. Sellers should therefore be cautious about broad regional restrictions. Check the area against your own plans before you agree it. A non-compete clause stops the seller being involved in a competing dental practice. It applies for a defined period and within a defined area. A non-solicitation clause is narrower. It stops the seller encouraging patients, referral sources, staff, associates or suppliers to leave the sold practice. Non-solicitation clauses are often easier to justify, because they target active interference rather than all competing activity. Separate, targeted clauses may work better than one broad clause trying to cover everything. That depends on the covenants you agree. A seller should not accept restrictions that unnecessarily stop them earning a living or continuing a clinical career. You may want to keep working, teach, consult or work outside the area. You may also want to provide services that do not compete with the sold practice. If so, ask for carve-outs before you sign. If you have already agreed a future role, check the covenants against that plan. Take advice before agreeing heads of terms. Not if the sale agreement includes staff and associate protections. These clauses stop the seller recruiting or encouraging employees, associates, hygienists or key team members to leave. They should say which people they protect and for how long. They should also say whether they only cover people the seller had material dealings with. They must go no further than is necessary and proportionate. They should also fit with employment law, TUPE obligations and associate agreements. Act quickly, because delay can make it harder to protect goodwill once patients, staff or referral contacts start moving. Possible remedies include an injunction, damages or other contractual remedies. An injunction is a court order to stop doing something. Damages are financial compensation for loss. First, gather evidence carefully and check exactly what the clause prohibits. Working elsewhere is not always a breach. Sellers facing an allegation should take it seriously and get early advice. Yes. The courts generally treat restrictions in a business sale differently from those in an ordinary employment contract. A seller who receives payment for goodwill may have to accept more substantial restrictions than an employee leaving a job. However, that does not mean anything goes. The restriction must still be properly targeted. Where relevant, competition law also applies. The parties should still be able to justify its duration, geography and activities, so make sure each clause matches a real commercial risk. Early, ideally at heads of terms stage. Restrictive covenants in dental practice sales affect the commercial bargain. They may influence the price, the handover and the seller’s future plans. If they first come up late in the drafting, they can cause tension and delay. Heads of terms should say which restrictions the seller will give. They should also set out the proposed duration, the restricted area and any obvious carve-outs. Read our guide to heads of terms when buying or selling a dental practice.
Contact us
We provide most enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate, based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.
In the same email you will be invited to arrange a 20-minute complimentary, no-obligation video consultation, should the proposed scope of work and fee estimate be of interest. This initial discussion is designed to better understand your requirements, refine the scope and ensure our approach is fully aligned with your objectives, at the end of which we will email you a definitive formal fee estimate to consider and approve.
Where you would prefer to receive initial advice and guidance from the outset, or where a short introductory call would not be the most appropriate starting point, we may instead recommend a 2.5-hour fixed-fee appointment, starting from £700 + VAT. This enables us to review the information you provide, discuss your situation with you and provide considered, tailored advice at an early stage.
To make an enquiry, please email us at wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net, complete our contact form, or call us on 01444 708640.
VAT is charged at 20%.
This article is intended for general information only, applies to the law at the time of publication, is not specific to the facts of your case and is not intended to be a replacement for legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before relying on any of the information given. © Jonathan Lea Limited.