Employment-Related Corporate Tax: Structuring Incentives with Technical Discipline
Employment-related corporate tax sits at the intersection of tax law, company law and employment regulation. When companies incentivise directors, senior management or employees with equity or equity-linked arrangements, the tax consequences can be significant — for both the individual and the company.
Improper structuring can result in unexpected income tax and NIC liabilities, loss of reliefs, corporation tax disallowance, or HMRC challenge. Proper structuring, by contrast, can align incentives, preserve tax efficiency and support growth.
At Jonathan Lea Network, we advise companies on the design, implementation and ongoing compliance of employment-related equity and reward arrangements.
The Employment-Related Securities Regime
Most equity provided to employees or directors falls within the UK’s employment-related securities (ERS) regime.
This means:
- Income tax and NIC can arise on acquisition, vesting or disposal
- Market value assessments are critical
- Reporting obligations apply
- Anti-avoidance provisions may apply where arrangements are structured artificially
Even where commercial objectives are clear, the tax treatment depends on detailed statutory analysis and factual evidence.
EMI and Tax-Advantaged Option Schemes
Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) schemes are often the preferred route for growth companies seeking to incentivise key personnel.
When properly structured, EMI can provide:
- No income tax on grant
- Capital gains tax treatment on exit (subject to conditions)
- Corporation tax deductions for the company
However, eligibility criteria are strict. Issues commonly arise around:
- Trading activity tests
- Gross asset thresholds
- Working time requirements
- Market value agreement with HMRC
- Disqualifying events
Failure to meet ongoing conditions can jeopardise relief.
EMI eligibility thresholds and notification processes are subject to legislative update, including changes taking effect from April 2026. Scheme design and compliance procedures should therefore always be reviewed against current law to ensure continued qualification.
We advise on scheme design, documentation, valuation processes and HMRC notifications to preserve tax-advantaged status.
Growth Shares and Sweet Equity
In private equity and investor-backed transactions, management equity is often structured using:
- Growth shares
- Flowering shares
- Sweet equity
- Ratchet mechanisms
These arrangements must balance:
- Commercial incentive alignment
- Income tax risk at acquisition
- Employment-related securities exposure
- Valuation defensibility
Where growth shares are issued at undervalue, income tax and NIC may arise at the outset. Careful valuation methodology and drafting are therefore essential.
Unapproved Share Options and Other Arrangements
Not all businesses qualify for EMI or other tax-advantaged schemes.
Alternative structures may include:
- Unapproved share options
- Joint share ownership plans
- Restricted share awards
- Phantom equity or cash-settled incentives
Each carries distinct income tax, NIC and corporation tax implications.
We assess suitability in light of:
- Company size and activity
- Shareholder structure
- Future investment plans
- Exit horizon
Corporation Tax Deductions
Companies may be entitled to corporation tax deductions in respect of certain employee share awards or option exercises.
However:
- The timing of relief depends on statutory rules
- Accounting treatment and tax treatment may differ
- Relief may be restricted in some circumstances
Integration between tax planning and financial reporting is therefore important.
Reporting and Compliance Obligations
The ERS regime imposes annual reporting requirements to HMRC for relevant share and option arrangements.
Obligations include:
- Registration of schemes
- Annual ERS returns
- Reporting of reportable events
- Notification of disqualifying events (for EMI)
Failure to comply can result in penalties and, in some cases, loss of tax-advantaged status.
We assist with ongoing compliance frameworks to reduce administrative risk.
Transactional Context: Investment and Exit
Employment-related tax issues frequently arise in:
- Private equity investments
- Management buy-outs
- Corporate reorganisations
- Trade sales
In these contexts, careful planning is required to address:
- Leaver provisions
- Good and bad leaver tax treatment
- Acceleration of vesting
- Exchange of shares
- Rollover of management equity
Tax treatment can materially affect net proceeds and negotiation leverage.
Anti-Avoidance and HMRC Scrutiny
Employment-related equity is an area of sustained HMRC attention.
Relief may be denied, or income tax recharacterised, where:
- Arrangements lack commercial substance
- Valuations are unsupported
- Structures are viewed as designed primarily to secure a tax advantage
Even where there is a genuine commercial rationale, inadequate documentation or flawed implementation can create exposure.
Up-to-date advice is essential, as legislation and HMRC guidance evolve regularly.
Our Approach
We provide:
- Scheme design and structuring advice
- EMI implementation and HMRC valuation liaison
- Growth share structuring and valuation analysis
- Drafting of option agreements and share documentation
- ERS compliance support
- Transactional tax advice in investment and exit scenarios
Our focus is to align commercial incentive objectives with technically defensible tax outcomes.
Aligning Incentives Without Creating Tax Risk
Equity-based incentives can be powerful tools for growth, retention and value creation. However, their tax treatment is complex and fact-sensitive. With careful structuring and disciplined compliance, companies can implement employment-related equity arrangements that are efficient, robust and aligned with long-term strategy. If you are designing or reviewing employee equity arrangements, early specialist input can prevent avoidable tax exposure and preserve intended reliefs.
Incentivising Growth Without Creating Exposure
Employment-related equity sits within one of the most technically complex areas of UK tax legislation. Reliefs are available, but only where eligibility criteria, valuation methodology and compliance processes are handled with precision.
Early structuring, before options are granted or shares are issued, materially reduces the risk of income tax re-characterisation, relief loss or HMRC enquiry.
If you are implementing, restructuring or reviewing an employee incentive arrangement, speak to our employment-related corporate tax team at the outset.
A technically disciplined approach ensures incentives remain commercially effective and tax-efficient over the long term.
Call us on 01444 708640 or email wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net to arrange a confidential discussion.
FAQ: Employment-Related Corporate Tax
Shares are treated as employment-related securities if they are made available by reason of employment, broadly construed. This can apply even where full market value is paid. The key risk is not undervalue at acquisition, but subsequent events (for example, lifting of restrictions) triggering income tax charges under Part 7 ITEPA 2003. If a joint section 431 election is not entered into on acquisition of restricted shares, future “chargeable events” (such as lifting of restrictions or disposal) can trigger income tax and NIC on growth that would otherwise have been taxed as capital. Failure to address this at the outset is a common source of unexpected exposure. Disqualifying events can include changes in trading activities, breaches of working time requirements, or certain corporate transactions. If not managed properly, they can alter the tax treatment of option gains. The timing of exercise following a disqualifying event is critical in determining whether favourable treatment is preserved. Growth share arrangements depend heavily on defensible market value analysis, including hurdle mechanics and rights differentials. HMRC will scrutinise assumptions around enterprise value, liquidity discounts and minority rights. Unsupported valuations can convert intended capital treatment into income tax exposure at acquisition.
Corporation tax relief is typically linked to the amount taxed on employees, but timing mismatches and technical statutory conditions can affect deductibility. In some cases, accounting treatment diverges from tax relief timing, and relief may be restricted where arrangements fall outside qualifying parameters.
Photo by Austin Distel on Unsplash
Our Corporate Tax Team
What Our Clients Say
Request a Free
No Obligation
20 Minute Call
This introductory call is to discuss your matter so we can provide a well-considered quote.
However, please be aware that the free 20 minute call is at our discretion. If you are more looking for advice and guidance on an initial call, we may instead offer a one-hour fixed fee appointment instead.
Our fixed fee appointments are between £250 plus VAT to £350 plus VAT* depending on the complexity of the issues and seniority of solicitor taking the call