
Shareholder Valuation Disputes
At Jonathan Lea Network, we understand that you want more than an explanation of how shares are valued. You want to know whether the proposed figure is reasonable, what you can do if you disagree and how to reach a resolution without unnecessary cost or disruption. We provide clear, commercially focused advice to help you understand your position, challenge valuations where appropriate and negotiate terms that protect your interests.
How Can We Help You Resolve a Share Valuation Dispute?
A disagreement about share value does not always mean someone is being unreasonable. Different valuation methods, financial assumptions or interpretations of company documents can produce significantly different figures.
However, understanding why those figures differ is essential before deciding whether to accept an offer, challenge a valuation or take further action.
Our share valuation dispute solicitors can help you:
- Understand whether a proposed valuation is reasonable. We review the legal basis for the valuation and work with accountants or independent valuation experts where necessary. This helps identify whether the correct process and assumptions have been used.
- Challenge an unfair or incorrect valuation. If you believe your shares have been undervalued, or another shareholder’s valuation is excessive, we can help you examine the evidence and identify grounds for challenging the figure.
- Protect your rights under existing agreements. Your shareholders’ agreement or articles of association may contain specific rules about valuing shares. We can explain how those rules apply and whether the agreed process has been followed.
- Negotiate a practical resolution. We can help you engage with the other shareholders, their advisers or an independent expert. Our aim is to resolve the disagreement efficiently wherever possible.
Whether you’re selling, buying or facing a compulsory transfer of shares, we focus on achieving an outcome that reflects your legal rights and commercial objectives.
What Causes Share Valuation Disputes?
Share valuation disputes often arise when shareholders have different expectations about the value of a company or the price that should be paid for a particular shareholding.
Unlike shares in publicly traded companies, private company shares do not usually have an easily identifiable market price. As a result, determining their value often involves professional judgement and assumptions about the company’s financial position and future prospects.
Disagreements during a shareholder buyout
Perhaps one shareholder wants to leave while the other wants to continue running the business. Both may agree that a buyout makes sense, but neither agrees on the price.
The departing shareholder may focus on the company’s growth and future potential. Meanwhile, the buyer may be concerned about debt, customer concentration or the cost of funding the purchase.
We help clients assess the basis of each valuation and explore ways to bridge the gap.
If you’re considering buying or selling a shareholding, our shareholder buyout solicitors can also help you negotiate and complete the transaction once the valuation issues have been resolved.
Disputes following a director or employee’s departure
Valuation disagreements can arise when a shareholder leaves their employment or directorship and is required to sell their shares.
The company’s agreements may distinguish between different types of departure, sometimes described as good leaver and bad leaver provisions. These can affect the price payable.
We can review whether the relevant provisions apply, whether the correct procedure has been followed and whether there are grounds to challenge the proposed valuation or leaver classification.
Concerns about the company’s financial information
A valuation may rely on accounts, forecasts or financial information that one shareholder believes are incomplete or inaccurate.
For example, there may be disagreement over directors’ remuneration, shareholder loans, unusual expenses or the value of company assets.
We help establish what information is relevant, whether there are rights to obtain it and how any concerns should be addressed through the valuation process.
What If You Think Your Shares Are Being Undervalued?
If you believe your shares are worth more than the price being offered, you should understand how the figure was calculated before accepting it.
An undervaluation can have serious financial consequences, particularly where you’ve spent years building the business or your shareholding represents a significant proportion of your personal wealth.
However, the fact that an offer is lower than your expectations does not automatically mean it is legally unfair.
Understanding how the valuation was reached
We begin by looking at the reason for the proposed sale, the rights attached to your shares and any contractual valuation rules.
We then consider the assumptions underlying the valuation and whether the relevant financial information has been properly taken into account.
Where appropriate, we work alongside independent valuation specialists to examine whether the valuation is commercially defensible.
Challenging the proposed figure
If concerns are identified, we can help you set out a reasoned challenge supported by the relevant contractual provisions and financial evidence.
This may involve requesting further information, questioning particular assumptions or seeking an independent valuation.
Our aim is to help you make an informed decision about whether to negotiate, pursue a formal valuation procedure or explore other remedies.
What If Another Shareholder Is Asking Too Much for Their Shares?
Share valuation disputes can be equally difficult when you’re the person expected to pay.
You may want to buy out another shareholder so you can take the business forward, but their asking price may be significantly higher than you believe the shares are worth.
Agreeing to an excessive price could place financial pressure on you or the business, particularly if the purchase is being funded through borrowing or deferred payments.
Establishing a realistic valuation
We can help you examine whether the proposed valuation reflects the company’s financial position, future earnings and relevant commercial risks.
We also consider whether the shareholding carries particular rights or restrictions that affect its value.
Keeping negotiations constructive
You may need to maintain a working relationship with the other shareholder while the disagreement is resolved.
We can help you negotiate from a well-supported position, avoid unnecessary confrontation and consider practical alternatives where the parties remain some distance apart.
These might include a jointly instructed independent valuer, a structured negotiation process or a different payment arrangement, depending on the circumstances.
How Are Shares in a Private Company Valued?
There is no single method that applies to every private company. The appropriate approach depends on the nature of the business, the rights attached to the shares and the circumstances in which the valuation is required.
An accountant or specialist valuer will usually assess the financial value. Our role is to advise on the legal framework, the applicable valuation rules and any dispute about how the valuation should be carried out.
Valuation based on profits or earnings
Some businesses are valued by reference to their profits or earnings, adjusted where necessary to reflect unusual income or expenses.
A valuation expert may apply a suitable multiple to those earnings to estimate the value of the business.
Disputes can arise over which earnings figures should be used, the adjustments made and the appropriate multiple.
Valuation based on assets
Where a company owns significant property, investments or other valuable assets, an asset-based valuation may be appropriate.
This involves considering the value of the company’s assets alongside its liabilities.
Shareholders may disagree about property values, outstanding debts or whether the accounts accurately reflect the company’s financial position.
Valuation based on future cash flow
Some valuations consider the cash the business is expected to generate in the future.
This can be particularly sensitive to assumptions about growth, profitability and risk.
Even relatively small differences in forecasts can produce substantially different valuations.
For a more detailed explanation of the financial methods involved, see our guide to private company valuations for shareholder buyouts.
Can a Minority Shareholding Be Valued at a Discount?
A minority shareholding may sometimes be valued at a discount because its owner has less control over the company and may find it harder to sell their shares.
However, a minority discount is not automatic.
Whether one applies depends on the relevant agreements, the purpose of the valuation and the circumstances of the dispute.
Why minority discounts cause disagreements
Suppose you own 25% of a company valued at £2 million.
You might reasonably start by expecting your shares to be worth £500,000. However, another shareholder may argue that your holding should be worth less because it does not give you control over the company.
That argument may or may not be appropriate, depending on the circumstances.
When a discount may be inappropriate
The company’s articles or shareholders’ agreement may specify how the valuation should be carried out.
In some unfair prejudice cases, the court may also decide that valuing a minority shareholding without a discount is appropriate.
We can help you understand whether a discount is legally and commercially justified, rather than simply accepting the other party’s position.
What Do Your Shareholders’ Agreement and Articles Say About Valuation?
Before challenging a share valuation, it is important to establish whether the company already has rules governing how the shares must be valued.
Your shareholders’ agreement or articles of association may contain a valuation procedure that becomes relevant when a shareholder leaves, retires or is required to transfer shares.
These provisions can have a significant effect on the outcome.
Agreed valuation methods
Your documents may specify a formula for calculating share value or require an independent professional to determine the price.
They may also identify the date on which the shares must be valued and whether particular adjustments are permitted.
Appointment of an independent expert
Some agreements require an independent accountant or valuation expert to determine the share price where the shareholders cannot agree.
The expert’s decision may be binding, depending on the terms of the agreement and the expert’s appointment.
We can advise on the appointment process, the expert’s authority and the limited circumstances in which a determination might be challenged.
Disputes over interpretation
Sometimes the disagreement is not about the underlying financial figures, but about what the relevant contractual provisions mean.
For example, the parties may disagree over whether a discount should apply or whether a departing shareholder falls within a particular leaver category.
We can assess the documents and advise on how the provisions should operate.
For further guidance, read our article on articles of association and shareholders’ agreements.
What Happens If Shareholders Cannot Agree on a Valuation?
When negotiations reach a standstill, there may still be several ways to resolve the disagreement without going to court.
The most appropriate option depends on the company’s agreements, the nature of the dispute and the extent of the difference between the parties’ positions.
Negotiation
A reasoned exchange of valuations, assumptions and supporting financial information may help narrow the issues.
We can represent you in discussions with the other shareholders and their advisers, focusing on a commercially workable outcome.
Independent expert determination
Where the company’s documents provide for expert determination, an appropriately qualified professional may be appointed to decide the valuation.
Even without an existing clause, the parties may agree to use an independent expert.
We can help establish the terms of the appointment and ensure the process addresses the relevant issues.
Mediation
Mediation allows the parties to explore possible solutions with the assistance of an independent mediator.
It can be particularly useful where the valuation dispute forms part of a wider disagreement about the business or the shareholders’ relationship.
Court proceedings
Where the dispute cannot be resolved through negotiation or another agreed procedure, court proceedings may be necessary.
The appropriate claim depends on the facts and the legal rights involved. A valuation disagreement alone does not automatically provide grounds for court action.
Our shareholder and director dispute solicitors can advise on the available remedies and the risks of pursuing or defending a claim.
Can You Take Legal Action Over an Unfair Share Valuation?
You may have grounds for legal action where a valuation breaches the company’s agreements or forms part of conduct that unfairly harms your interests as a shareholder.
However, the available remedies depend on the circumstances.
Breach of an agreed valuation procedure
If another shareholder fails to follow a binding valuation mechanism, it may be possible to enforce the relevant contractual rights.
For example, the agreement may require an independent expert to determine the price rather than allowing one shareholder to choose it.
We can advise on whether the procedure has been followed and what action may be appropriate.
Unfair prejudice claims
Sometimes an undervaluation forms part of wider unfair treatment.
For example, a shareholder may have been excluded from management, denied information they are entitled to receive or subjected to conduct that has reduced the value of their investment.
Under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006, a shareholder may be able to bring an unfair prejudice petition if the statutory requirements are met.
If the claim succeeds, the court has wide powers to grant relief under section 996, including ordering a purchase of shares on terms the court considers appropriate.
However, not every disagreement about value amounts to unfair prejudice. We can help you assess whether there are grounds for a claim and whether pursuing one is commercially sensible.
Why Choose Jonathan Lea Network for Share Valuation Disputes?
A share valuation dispute requires more than understanding financial figures. It also involves knowing your legal rights, the commercial pressures surrounding the disagreement and the outcome you want to achieve.
At Jonathan Lea Network, we combine corporate and dispute resolution expertise to help shareholders and business owners address these issues in a practical, joined-up way.
Commercial advice that considers the bigger picture
We understand that a valuation disagreement can affect your finances, business relationships and future plans.
We take time to understand what you want to achieve and explain the realistic options available, including the risks and likely costs associated with each approach.
Working alongside valuation specialists
We can work with accountants and independent valuation experts where specialist financial evidence is required.
This allows us to focus on the legal issues while ensuring the financial aspects of the dispute receive appropriate expert attention.
A proportionate approach to resolving disagreements
Court proceedings are not always the best starting point.
We consider whether the dispute can be resolved through negotiation, expert determination or mediation before recommending more formal action.
Where litigation is necessary, we can advise on the strength of your position and represent your interests.
Our solicitors assist clients in Sussex and across England and Wales, providing straightforward advice focused on protecting their interests and achieving commercially sensible outcomes.
What Is the Process for Resolving a Share Valuation Dispute?
We aim to make the process clear from the outset so you understand what needs to happen and why.
- Understanding your situation
We start by discussing the disagreement, the valuation figures being proposed and what you want to achieve.
We also consider whether any immediate deadlines, contractual procedures or proposed share transfers need attention.
- Reviewing the relevant documents
We examine the shareholders’ agreement, articles of association and any other relevant documents.
Where necessary, we also review financial information, previous valuations and correspondence between the parties.
- Assessing your options
We explain whether there are grounds to challenge the valuation, what additional evidence may be required and which approach is likely to be proportionate.
If specialist valuation advice is necessary, we can help coordinate the appropriate professionals.
- Negotiating or pursuing a resolution
Depending on your position, we may assist with correspondence, negotiations, expert determination, mediation or court proceedings.
Throughout the process, we keep your financial interests and wider commercial objectives in mind.
How Long Do Share Valuation Disputes Take and What Will It Cost?
The time required depends on the nature of the disagreement, the documents involved and whether the parties are willing to negotiate.
A relatively straightforward dispute may be resolved through an exchange of information or an independent valuation.
More complex cases can take longer, particularly where financial records are disputed, expert evidence is required or court proceedings become necessary.
Our fees depend on the scope and complexity of the work. We will explain our proposed approach and provide a fee estimate before you decide whether to proceed.
Where appropriate, we may recommend addressing a specific issue first, such as interpreting a valuation clause or reviewing an expert’s report, rather than committing immediately to a wider dispute process.
Contact Us
We provide most enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate, based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.
In the same email you will be invited to arrange a 20-minute complimentary, no-obligation video consultation, should the proposed scope of work and fee estimate be of interest. This initial discussion is designed to better understand your requirements, refine the scope and ensure our approach is fully aligned with your objectives, at the end of which we will email you a definitive formal fee estimate to consider and approve.
Where you would prefer to receive initial advice and guidance from the outset, or where a short introductory call would not be the most appropriate starting point, we may instead recommend a 2.5-hour fixed-fee appointment, starting from £750 + VAT. This enables us to review the information you provide, discuss your situation with you and provide considered, tailored advice at an early stage.
To make an enquiry, please email us at wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net, complete our contact form, or call us on 01444 708640.
VAT is charged at 20%.
This page is intended for general information only, applies to the law at the time of publication, is not specific to the facts of your case and is not intended to be a replacement for legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before relying on any of the information given. © Jonathan Lea Limited.
Frequently Asked Questions About Share Valuation Disputes
-
Can I challenge the valuation of my shares?
-
Yes, you may be able to challenge a share valuation if the agreed procedure has not been followed, the valuation is based on incorrect information or there are other recognised legal grounds. However, simply disagreeing with the figure is not necessarily enough. We can review the relevant agreements and evidence to establish whether a challenge is available.
-
Who decides how much my shares are worth?
-
This depends on the company’s agreements and the circumstances of the valuation. The shareholders may agree a price themselves or appoint an independent valuation expert. Where a binding valuation procedure applies, that process will usually need to be followed. In certain court proceedings, the court may determine or direct how the value should be assessed.
-
Can I request an independent share valuation?
-
You can propose an independent valuation, but you may not be able to require one unless your contractual or legal rights provide for it. Some shareholders’ agreements contain provisions requiring an expert to determine share value. We can review your documents and advise whether an independent valuation can be requested or enforced.
-
Do minority shareholders have to accept a lower share valuation?
-
No, a lower valuation is not automatic simply because you hold a minority shareholding. Whether a minority discount applies depends on the valuation terms, the rights attached to the shares and the circumstances. In some cases, particularly certain unfair prejudice claims, a valuation without a minority discount may be appropriate.
-
What happens if an independent valuer makes a mistake?
-
Your options depend on the expert’s terms of appointment and whether their determination is contractually binding. An expert’s decision is not necessarily open to challenge simply because one party disagrees with it. However, a challenge may be possible in limited circumstances, such as where the expert has acted outside their authority. Legal advice should be obtained before taking further action.
-
Can a shareholder refuse to provide financial information for a valuation?
-
A shareholder or company may have obligations to provide information under a shareholders’ agreement, articles of association or other applicable legal provisions. However, shareholders do not have an unrestricted right to inspect every company record. We can assess what information you are entitled to receive and advise on the steps available if relevant information is being withheld.
-
Can I recover my legal costs if I win a share valuation dispute?
-
Possibly, but recovering costs is not guaranteed. In court proceedings, the court has discretion over costs, and even a successful party may not recover everything they have spent. Negotiation, mediation and expert determination may involve different costs arrangements. We can explain the likely financial implications before you decide how to proceed.
-
What if the company's value changes while the dispute is ongoing?
-
Changes in the company’s performance, assets or financial position may affect its value. However, whether those changes are taken into account depends on the applicable valuation date, contractual provisions and circumstances. Establishing the correct valuation date can therefore be an important part of the dispute, particularly where the company has experienced significant growth or financial difficulties.
Take Action Today
Whether you are defending your position, bringing a claim against another director, or seeking to understand your obligations, it is vital to act promptly. Delay can limit your options, increase costs, and worsen the impact on your business.
Call+44 (0)1444 708 640 to arrange a free initial consultation.
Or use our simple online enquiry form and one of our expert solicitors will be in touch.
Please do get in touch with us so that we can utilise our expertise to steer you to the most suitable outcome.
Our Partnership Disputes Team
What Our Clients Say
Request a Free
No Obligation
20 Minute Call
We provide most enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate, based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.
In the same email you will be invited to arrange a 20-minute complimentary, no-obligation video consultation, should the proposed scope of work and fee estimate be of interest. This initial discussion is designed to better understand your requirements, refine the scope and ensure our approach is fully aligned with your objectives, at the end of which we will email you a definitive formal fee estimate to consider and approve.
Where you would prefer to receive initial advice and guidance from the outset, or where a short introductory call would not be the most appropriate starting point, we may instead recommend a 2.5-hour fixed-fee appointment, starting from £750 + VAT. This enables us to review the information you provide, discuss your situation with you and provide considered, tailored advice at an early stage.
To make an enquiry, please email us at wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net, complete the form or call us on 01444 708640.



