
Director Duty Claims
These situations can be particularly difficult when the people involved have worked together for years or helped build the company from the ground up. Disagreements can quickly affect working relationships, disrupt the business and create uncertainty about who is responsible for what.
At Jonathan Lea Network, we understand that you need clear answers and a practical way forward. Whether you want to recover money, protect the company from further harm or defend yourself against an unjustified claim, we can help you understand your position, assess the evidence and explore the most effective way to resolve the matter.
How Can Our Solicitors Help with Director Duty Claims?
When concerns arise about a director’s conduct, getting advice early can help you protect your position and avoid making the disagreement worse.
Not every poor business decision amounts to a breach of duty. Equally, serious misconduct should not be ignored simply because the director is also a shareholder or longstanding business partner.
We advise both parties bringing director duty claims and those defending them, although we would never act for opposing parties in the same dispute.
We can help you:
- Investigate suspected wrongdoing. We review the relevant decisions, company records and available financial evidence. This helps establish whether there may have been a breach of duty and what consequences followed.
- Recover losses or improperly obtained benefits. Where a director has breached their obligations, we can assess whether the company has grounds to seek compensation, repayment or another remedy. We also consider the cost and practicality of recovery.
- Defend allegations against you. If you’re accused of misconduct, we can assess the allegations, review the evidence and develop an appropriate response. Our aim is to protect your legal position and reputation.
- Resolve disputes through negotiation. Where appropriate, we explore settlement before recommending court proceedings. We can also advise on mediation and other ways to resolve the disagreement.
- Take or defend legal proceedings. Where a negotiated outcome is not possible, we can advise on the appropriate claim, available defences and potential financial consequences.
Our focus is on finding a proportionate solution that reflects your commercial objectives.
What Duties Do Company Directors Owe?
Company directors have legal responsibilities designed to ensure they exercise their powers properly and act in the company’s interests.
The main duties are set out in sections 171 to 177 of the Companies Act 2006.
These include duties to act within their powers, promote the success of the company, exercise independent judgement and use reasonable care, skill and diligence.
Directors must also avoid certain conflicts of interest, refrain from accepting improper benefits from third parties and declare relevant interests in proposed transactions.
What do these duties mean in practice?
A director should make decisions for proper purposes, consider relevant information and exercise appropriate care.
For example, a director may face questions if they use company funds for personal purposes, award contracts to a connected business without addressing a conflict of interest or divert a valuable opportunity away from the company.
However, a decision that turns out badly is not necessarily a breach of duty. The circumstances and the director’s conduct must be assessed against the relevant legal standards.
What Happens If a Director Breaches Their Duties?
A breach of directors’ duties can have significant financial and commercial consequences, depending on what happened and whether the company suffered a loss or the director obtained an improper benefit.
Potential remedies include compensation, repayment of company money, recovery of profits made through wrongdoing or an injunction to prevent further harmful conduct.
Recovering financial losses
If a director’s breach has caused the company financial loss, the company may be able to pursue compensation.
The amount recoverable will depend on the relevant duty, the loss and the applicable legal principles.
Recovering improper profits
In some circumstances, a director may have to account for profits obtained through a breach of duty, even where the company cannot establish a corresponding financial loss.
For example, this may arise where a director improperly takes a business opportunity for their own benefit.
Stopping ongoing misconduct
If the alleged breach is continuing or imminent, an injunction may be appropriate.
An injunction is a court order requiring someone to do, or stop doing, something. Applications can be urgent and involve significant costs risks.
We can assess whether protective action is available and proportionate.
Can You Take Action If a Director Has Misused Company Money?
If you suspect that a director has taken company money without proper authority, it is important to establish what the payments were for and whether they were legitimate.
You may have discovered unexplained transfers, substantial personal expenses or payments to businesses connected with the director.
Establishing what happened
Not every payment to a director is improper.
Salary, dividends, expense reimbursements and loan repayments may be legitimate if properly authorised and made in accordance with the law.
However, unexplained payments, unauthorised withdrawals or transactions designed to benefit the director personally may justify further investigation.
Taking steps to recover money
We can help the company review the evidence and assess whether repayment or another remedy is available.
Where appropriate, we may recommend seeking an explanation, preserving financial records or obtaining specialist accounting evidence.
If there is a risk that funds or assets will be moved beyond recovery, urgent legal remedies may need to be considered.
What If a Director Has Put Their Own Interests Before the Company?
Directors must deal properly with conflicts between their personal interests and the interests of the company.
Concerns may arise where a director operates a competing business, benefits from company opportunities or enters into transactions involving people or businesses connected with them.
Conflicts of interest
A conflict does not always mean a director has acted unlawfully.
Some conflicts can be authorised in accordance with the Companies Act 2006 and the company’s governing documents.
However, a director who fails to address a relevant conflict may face a claim, particularly where they have obtained an improper benefit.
Competing businesses and lost opportunities
You may discover that a director has redirected customers, contracts or business opportunities to another company.
We can assess whether the conduct breached the director’s duties or other obligations, and whether the company has grounds to recover losses or profits.
We can also advise on protecting confidential information and preventing further misuse.
For related advice, see our commercial dispute resolution services.
Can a Shareholder Bring a Director Duty Claim?
A shareholder who suspects a director has harmed the company may want to take action personally.
However, directors generally owe their statutory duties to the company, rather than directly to individual shareholders.
This distinction affects who can bring a claim and what remedy is available.
Claims brought by the company
Where the company has suffered loss because of a director’s breach, it will ordinarily be the company that brings the claim.
The company’s authorised decision-makers must determine whether proceedings should be pursued, subject to applicable governance rules.
Derivative claims brought by shareholders
In certain circumstances, a shareholder may seek permission from the court to bring a claim on the company’s behalf.
This is known as a derivative claim. It is governed principally by sections 260 to 264 of the Companies Act 2006.
The court’s permission is generally required, and specific statutory criteria apply.
Any recovery will normally benefit the company rather than being paid directly to the shareholder.
When another shareholder remedy may be appropriate
If the alleged wrongdoing has also unfairly harmed your interests as a shareholder, an unfair prejudice claim may be relevant.
However, the two procedures are different and should not be confused.
Our shareholder and director dispute solicitors can help identify the most appropriate route.
What Should You Do If You’re Accused of Breaching Your Director Duties?
Receiving an allegation that you’ve acted improperly can be unsettling, particularly if you believe you made decisions in good faith and in the company’s interests.
You may be concerned about personal liability, losing your position or damage to your professional reputation.
However, an allegation does not establish that a breach has occurred.
Understand exactly what is being alleged
The first step is to identify which duties are said to have been breached and what conduct is being challenged.
We review correspondence, company records, agreements and the relevant circumstances to assess the allegations.
Preserve relevant evidence
Board minutes, emails, financial information and professional advice obtained at the time may be important.
You should preserve relevant material without deleting records or improperly accessing confidential company information.
Avoid responding without advice
A detailed response written in haste can create problems if it contains inaccuracies or unintended admissions.
We can help you prepare an appropriate response and assess whether further information should be requested.
Consider whether a settlement is possible
Not every allegation needs to result in litigation.
Depending on the circumstances, it may be possible to resolve matters through an explanation, agreed repayment, settlement or another appropriate arrangement.
We help you assess the available options without assuming that accepting a settlement means admitting wrongdoing.
Can Directors Be Personally Liable for Company Losses?
Yes, directors can face personal liability where they breach duties owed to the company and the relevant legal requirements for a remedy are met.
However, directors are not automatically personally responsible whenever a company suffers financial losses.
Business decisions that do not work out
Running a business involves commercial risk.
A decision may be unsuccessful without the director having acted negligently or in breach of duty.
The question is whether the director complied with the relevant standards when making the decision.
Decisions involving negligence or misconduct
A director may face liability where they failed to exercise reasonable care, used company powers improperly or acted in breach of another duty.
The available remedies depend on the nature of the breach.
What if the director has resigned?
Leaving the company does not automatically remove liability for earlier conduct.
Certain duties concerning conflicts of interest and benefits from third parties can also continue in specific circumstances after a director leaves.
For guidance on the wider consequences of departing a company, see our article on removing a director for misconduct.
What If the Company Is Facing Financial Difficulties?
Allegations involving financially distressed companies require particular care because additional duties and insolvency-related remedies may become relevant.
Directors must pay proper attention to the interests of creditors when the legal threshold for the creditor duty is reached.
This does not mean that ordinary financial difficulties automatically make directors personally liable.
Decisions made during financial distress
Concerns may arise over payments to connected parties, repayment of director loans, disposal of company assets or continued trading.
The legality of these decisions depends on the company’s circumstances and the applicable duties.
Claims involving liquidators
If a company enters liquidation, a liquidator may investigate directors’ conduct and consider claims where there is evidence of wrongdoing.
These cases can involve different procedures and remedies from ordinary director duty claims.
Our dedicated director misfeasance and insolvency claims service provides further guidance.
You can also read our guide to directors’ duties in financial distress.
How Can Director Duty Claims Be Resolved Without Going to Court?
Many director duty claims can be resolved through negotiation, particularly where the parties understand the issues and are prepared to consider realistic solutions.
However, the appropriate approach depends on the seriousness of the allegations and whether urgent protection is required.
Negotiating a settlement
A settlement may involve repayment, compensation, the return of company property or agreed steps to prevent further problems.
We can help assess whether an offer reflects the strength of the claim and the commercial risks of continuing the dispute.
Mediation
An independent mediator can help the parties explore a resolution without imposing a decision.
This may be useful where the director and shareholders still need to maintain a working relationship.
Court proceedings
Where there is serious wrongdoing, a refusal to engage or no realistic prospect of settlement, formal proceedings may be necessary.
We can advise on the appropriate procedure, evidence required and potential costs before you decide whether to proceed.
Can a Company Remove a Director Who Has Breached Their Duties?
A company may be able to remove a director, but removing someone from office is separate from pursuing a claim for their past conduct.
Under section 168 of the Companies Act 2006, shareholders can generally remove a director by ordinary resolution at a meeting, subject to the required procedure.
Removing the director
The company’s articles, contracts and statutory requirements must be considered before taking action.
Removing a director may also have employment and shareholder consequences.
Pursuing a claim afterwards
A director’s removal does not automatically resolve any financial loss or wrongdoing that may have occurred.
The company may still have grounds to seek compensation or another remedy.
Equally, removal does not establish that the director breached their duties.
We can help assess both the governance and dispute resolution aspects of the situation.
Why Choose Jonathan Lea Network for Director Duty Claims?
A director duty claim can affect far more than the individuals directly involved. It can create uncertainty for the company, place pressure on business relationships and expose those involved to substantial financial risks.
At Jonathan Lea Network, we combine corporate and dispute resolution advice to help clients address these issues with a clear understanding of the commercial consequences.
Advice for both claimants and defendants
We represent businesses pursuing claims and directors defending allegations, subject to appropriate conflict checks.
This allows us to assess the legal issues from the relevant perspective while focusing on the evidence and the outcome our client wants to achieve.
Joined-up corporate expertise
Director duty claims can overlap with shareholder disputes, employment arrangements, company governance and insolvency concerns.
Our teams can work together to address these connected issues rather than treating each as a separate problem.
Practical, proportionate solutions
We recognise that legal proceedings can be costly and disruptive.
Our starting point is to establish the strength of your position, the evidence available and whether a commercially sensible settlement may be possible.
Where litigation is necessary, we can help you pursue or defend the claim with a clear strategy.
Our director duty claims solicitors advise companies, shareholders and directors in Sussex and across England and Wales.
What Is the Process for Bringing or Defending a Director Duty Claim?
We aim to give you a clear understanding of the process from the outset, so you know what needs to happen and what decisions you may need to make.
- Understanding the allegations
We begin by discussing what has happened, the parties involved and what you want to achieve.
We also identify whether any immediate steps are needed to preserve evidence or protect company assets.
- Reviewing the evidence
We examine relevant company records, correspondence, financial information and agreements.
Where necessary, we work with accountants or other specialists to assess the financial consequences.
- Assessing the legal position
We advise on whether a claim is available, who has standing to bring it, the strength of the evidence and any relevant defences.
We also explain the potential remedies, costs and risks.
- Developing a resolution strategy
Depending on the circumstances, we may recommend negotiation, mediation or formal legal proceedings.
We help you select an approach that reflects your objectives and the commercial value of the dispute.
- Pursuing or defending the claim
We manage correspondence, negotiations and any necessary proceedings, working with specialist counsel and experts where appropriate.
Throughout the matter, we keep you informed and continue to consider opportunities for resolution.
How Long Do Director Duty Claims Take and What Will They Cost?
The time and cost involved depend on the complexity of the allegations, the evidence available and whether the parties are willing to negotiate.
A straightforward disagreement may be resolved through correspondence or an agreed settlement.
More complex claims can involve detailed financial investigations, expert evidence and contested court proceedings.
We aim to assess proportionality at an early stage, including the value of any potential recovery and the costs of pursuing or defending the claim.
Our legal fees will depend on the work required. We will explain the proposed scope and provide a fee estimate before you decide whether to proceed.
Where appropriate, we may recommend an initial review of the allegations and supporting documents before committing to a wider dispute resolution strategy.
Contact Us
We provide most enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate, based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.
In the same email you will be invited to arrange a 20-minute complimentary, no-obligation video consultation, should the proposed scope of work and fee estimate be of interest. This initial discussion is designed to better understand your requirements, refine the scope and ensure our approach is fully aligned with your objectives, at the end of which we will email you a definitive formal fee estimate to consider and approve.
Where you would prefer to receive initial advice and guidance from the outset, or where a short introductory call would not be the most appropriate starting point, we may instead recommend a 2.5-hour fixed-fee appointment, starting from £750 + VAT. This enables us to review the information you provide, discuss your situation with you and provide considered, tailored advice at an early stage.
To make an enquiry, please email us at wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net, complete our contact form, or call us on 01444 708640.
Frequently Asked Questions About Director Duty Claims
-
Can a company sue a director for breach of duty?
-
Yes. A company can bring a claim against a current or former director where there are grounds to establish a breach of duty. Depending on the circumstances, the company may seek compensation, repayment or another appropriate remedy. The relevant company approvals and legal requirements must be considered before proceedings are started.
-
Can shareholders sue a director personally for breaching their duties?
-
Generally, the statutory duties under sections 171 to 177 of the Companies Act 2006 are owed to the company rather than individual shareholders. However, shareholders may be able to bring a derivative claim on the company’s behalf with the court’s permission. Other claims may be available where separate duties are owed directly to the shareholder or other legal grounds exist.
-
What evidence is needed to prove a breach of directors' duties?
-
The evidence depends on the alleged breach. Relevant material may include board minutes, company accounts, contracts, financial transactions and correspondence. It may also be necessary to establish financial loss or an improper benefit, depending on the remedy sought. We can help assess what evidence is required and whether specialist expert input would assist.
-
Can a director be personally liable even if they acted in good faith?
-
Potentially, yes. Acting in good faith is relevant to some duties, but it does not automatically protect a director from every claim. For example, a director may breach the duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence without acting dishonestly. The court will consider the particular duty, the circumstances and any applicable defence or relief.
-
Can a director be sued after resigning from the company?
-
Yes. Resignation does not automatically release a director from liability for breaches committed during their appointment. Certain duties can also continue to apply after departure in specified circumstances. The time available to bring a claim will depend on the legal basis of the action and any applicable limitation rules.
-
Can a breach of directors' duties be approved by shareholders?
-
In some circumstances, shareholders may ratify conduct amounting to negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust under section 239 of the Companies Act 2006. However, statutory requirements apply, including restrictions on votes cast by the director and connected members. Not every breach can be effectively ratified, and the company’s wider financial circumstances may also be relevant.
-
Can directors use insurance to cover breach of duty claims?
-
Directors’ and officers’ insurance may provide cover for certain claims and legal defence costs, depending on the policy. However, exclusions, notification requirements and limits may apply. Company indemnities are also restricted by law. We can help review the relevant arrangements and advise on what protection may be available.
-
Can a director be disqualified for breaching their duties?
-
Director disqualification may arise where the relevant statutory grounds are met, but it is not an automatic consequence of a civil breach of duty. Disqualification involves a separate legal framework under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986. We can help assess whether allegations create a wider risk of investigation or disqualification proceedings.
Take Action Today
Whether you are defending your position, bringing a claim against another director, or seeking to understand your obligations, it is vital to act promptly. Delay can limit your options, increase costs, and worsen the impact on your business.
Call+44 (0)1444 708 640 to arrange a free initial consultation.
Or use our simple online enquiry form and one of our expert solicitors will be in touch.
Please do get in touch with us so that we can utilise our expertise to steer you to the most suitable outcome.
VAT is charged at 20%.
This page is intended for general information only, applies to the law at the time of publication, is not specific to the facts of your case and is not intended to be a replacement for legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before relying on any of the information given. © Jonathan Lea Limited.
Our Partnership Disputes Team
What Our Clients Say
Request a Free
No Obligation
20 Minute Call
We provide most enquiries with an indicative scope of work and fee estimate, based on the information you share. We aim to respond within one working day.
In the same email you will be invited to arrange a 20-minute complimentary, no-obligation video consultation, should the proposed scope of work and fee estimate be of interest. This initial discussion is designed to better understand your requirements, refine the scope and ensure our approach is fully aligned with your objectives, at the end of which we will email you a definitive formal fee estimate to consider and approve.
Where you would prefer to receive initial advice and guidance from the outset, or where a short introductory call would not be the most appropriate starting point, we may instead recommend a 2.5-hour fixed-fee appointment, starting from £750 + VAT. This enables us to review the information you provide, discuss your situation with you and provide considered, tailored advice at an early stage.
To make an enquiry, please email us at wewillhelp@jonathanlea.net, complete the form or call us on 01444 708640.



